Zaim M, Ghavami M B, Nazari M, Edrissian G H, Nateghpour M
Department of Medical Entomology, School of Public Health, Teheran, Iran.
J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 1998 Dec;14(4):421-30.
In a study carried out in the Ghassreghand Division (Baluchistan, Iran) from March through November 1995, efficacy of cyfluthrin-impregnated bednets was compared to that of untreated nets, in relation to malaria control. Ten villages with a total population of 4,572 and 3 villages with a total population of 1,935 were used as treatment and control, respectively. The collection, impregnation (target dosage of 40 mg active ingredient [AI]/m2), and redistribution of the nets (9% nylon, 52% light cotton, 30% medium cotton, and 9% heavy cotton), carried out in mid-April, were done by local health workers, supervised by the senior research staff. Anopheles culicifacies was considered to be the main vector of malaria in the named area. This species is mainly zoophilic, endophilic, and exophagic. The initial uptake of the insecticide was lower than the target dosage, with high variation (nylon, 12.5 +/- 5.4 mg AI/m2; light cotton, 33.3 +/- 26.1 mg AI/m2; medium cotton, 25.9 +/- 20 mg AI/m2; heavy cotton, 17.6 +/- 12.5 mg AI/m2). The use of impregnated mosquito nets (used primarily outside) had no significant effect on the incidence of malaria. No difference was detected in the parasite density of patients with positive slides. No significant effect was observed in the parous rate, human blood index, and sporozoite rate of anopheline vectors. Only the indoor resting densities of An. culicifacies and other malaria vectors were drastically reduced after the introduction of the cyfluthrin-impregnated nets into the treatment villages. The residual activity of cyfluthrin was lower than expected. The mortality of anophelines brought in contact with the treated nets for 3 min in bioassays dropped to less than 55% in 3 months. The loss of chemical activity was greatest for the light cotton nets, followed by the medium cotton nets. Cyfluthrin-treated nets were mildly irritating to host-seeking female anophelines in the laboratory. The protective rate of impregnation (all fabric kinds included) in preventing female mosquitoes from biting through the impregnated nets was initially 5-6 times that of the nonimpregnated nets. The study did not detect any significant difference between the use of untreated versus impregnated bednets in the Ghassreghand area. In planning future medium-scale trials, comparison of new compounds and formulations to the more widely used pyrethroids such as permethrin and deltamethrin is highly recommended.
1995年3月至11月在伊朗俾路支省加什雷汉德分区开展了一项研究,就疟疾防治方面,将氟氯氰菊酯浸渍蚊帐的效果与未处理蚊帐的效果进行了比较。分别选取了总人口为4572人的10个村庄作为处理组,以及总人口为1935人的3个村庄作为对照组。4月中旬,当地卫生工作者在高级研究人员的监督下,负责蚊帐的收集、浸渍(活性成分[AI]目标剂量为40毫克/平方米)以及重新分配(9%尼龙、52%轻质棉、30%中质棉和9%重质棉)。库氏按蚊被认为是指定地区疟疾的主要传播媒介。该物种主要嗜动物性、嗜室内性和外食性。杀虫剂的初始吸收量低于目标剂量,且差异很大(尼龙,12.5±5.4毫克AI/平方米;轻质棉,33.3±26.1毫克AI/平方米;中质棉,25.9±20毫克AI/平方米;重质棉,17.6±12.5毫克AI/平方米)。使用浸渍蚊帐(主要在室外使用)对疟疾发病率没有显著影响。在阳性玻片患者的寄生虫密度方面未检测到差异。在按蚊媒介的经产率、人血指数和子孢子率方面未观察到显著影响。在处理组村庄引入氟氯氰菊酯浸渍蚊帐后,仅库氏按蚊和其他疟疾传播媒介的室内栖息密度大幅降低。氟氯氰菊酯的残留活性低于预期。在生物测定中,与处理过的蚊帐接触3分钟的按蚊死亡率在3个月内降至55%以下。化学活性损失在轻质棉蚊帐中最大,其次是中质棉蚊帐。在实验室中,经氟氯氰菊酯处理的蚊帐对寻找宿主的雌性按蚊有轻微刺激。浸渍(包括所有织物种类)在防止雌蚊叮咬浸渍蚊帐方面的保护率最初是非浸渍蚊帐的5至