Chee C B, Soh C H, Boudville I C, Chor S S, Wang Y T
Tuberculosis Control Unit, Department of Respiratory Medicine, and Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Tan Tock Seng Hospital, Singapore.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2001 Sep 15;164(6):958-61. doi: 10.1164/ajrccm.164.6.2101093.
Tuberculin skin test (TST) interpretation in Singapore is confounded by universal BCG vaccination at birth and by a revaccination policy for schoolchildren who are tuberculin nonreactors (TST < 10 mm, using 1 TU PPD RT 23) at 12 or 16 yr old, with not more than two BCG vaccinations given to any child. School health records for birth cohorts 1978 to 1984 indicate that 82.8% were revaccinated at age 12 yr. By collation with the national database of tuberculosis (TB) notifications, we examined the risk of TB disease in these cohorts for the 4 yr subsequent to TST reading at ages 12 and 16 yr respectively, in intervals of 0-4, 5-9, 10-14, 15-17, and >/= 18 mm. Receiver-operating curves (ROCs) were constructed to ascertain the optimum TST cutoffs in screening for the likelihood of development of TB disease. A cutoff of 10 mm performed best for the group tested at age 12 yr, whereas 16 mm was found to be optimum in those tested at age 16 yr (> 80% of whom were BCG revaccinated 4 yr earlier). We have extrapolated these findings to the screening of contacts, and utilized these cutoff points to guide the treatment of latent TB infection in this high-risk group.
在新加坡,结核菌素皮肤试验(TST)的结果解读受到两方面因素的干扰:一是全民在出生时接种卡介苗,二是针对12岁或16岁时结核菌素无反应者(TST<10mm,使用1TU PPD RT 23)的在校儿童复种政策,且任何儿童接种卡介苗不超过两次。1978年至1984年出生队列的学校健康记录显示,82.8%的儿童在12岁时进行了复种。通过与国家结核病通报数据库核对,我们分别检查了这些队列在12岁和16岁TST检测后4年中,TST结果分别为0 - 4、5 - 9、10 - 14、15 - 17及≥18mm时发生结核病的风险。构建了受试者工作特征曲线(ROC),以确定在筛查结核病发病可能性时的最佳TST临界值。对于12岁检测组,10mm的临界值表现最佳,而对于16岁检测组(其中80%以上在4年前进行了卡介苗复种),16mm被发现是最佳临界值。我们已将这些结果外推至接触者筛查,并利用这些临界值指导该高危组潜伏性结核感染的治疗。