Freshwater K, Leach C, Aldridge J
Psychological Health Services, Tees & North East Yorkshire NHS Trust, Hartlepool, UK.
Br J Med Psychol. 2001 Sep;74(Pt 3):379-97.
Within the theoretical framework of Ryle's Procedural Sequence Object Relations Model and Kelly's Personal Construct Theory, this study investigates sex-role polarization of incest survivors and the centrality of abuse within survivors' constructs of men that may contribute to revictimization. Repertory grid methodology was used with 40 female survivors of childhood sexual abuse and 28 non-abused women. Grid measures and psychometric measures were compared between groups of women who had and had not experienced childhood sexual abuse, revictimized and non-revictimized survivors, and survivors who had and had not experienced incestuous abuse. Results showed significant differences between survivors and non-abused women, with survivors having higher levels of depression and perceived distress, lower self-esteem and higher self/ ideal self discrepancy. Hypothesized differences in sex-role polarization were not found. There were few differences between revictimized and non-revictimized survivors, although revictimized survivors rated 'self now' as more powerful than non-revictimized survivors. No differences were found between survivors who had and had not experienced incestuous abuse. In addition to the value of exploring personal constructs, a range of models need to be considered in understanding revictimization and women's construal of men. The implications of using repertory grid methodology for research and clinical work are discussed.
在赖尔的程序序列客体关系模型和凯利的个人建构理论的理论框架内,本研究调查了乱伦幸存者的性别角色两极分化以及虐待在幸存者对男性的建构中的核心地位,这可能导致再次受害。对40名童年期性虐待女性幸存者和28名未受虐待女性使用了 repertory grid 方法。比较了经历和未经历童年期性虐待的女性群体、再次受害和未再次受害的幸存者以及经历和未经历乱伦虐待的幸存者之间的网格测量和心理测量。结果显示幸存者和未受虐待女性之间存在显著差异,幸存者的抑郁水平和感知痛苦更高,自尊更低,自我/理想自我差异更大。未发现性别角色两极分化的假设差异。再次受害和未再次受害的幸存者之间几乎没有差异,尽管再次受害的幸存者将“现在的自我”评为比未再次受害的幸存者更有力量。经历和未经历乱伦虐待的幸存者之间未发现差异。除了探索个人建构的价值外,在理解再次受害和女性对男性的理解时还需要考虑一系列模型。讨论了使用 repertory grid 方法进行研究和临床工作的意义。