Tian S, Wang J
Zhonghua Yi Shi Za Zhi. 1995;25(3):179-82.
This paper claims that all the materials, including the first chapter of Lu's Chun Qiu Shi Er Ji, the theory of Heart Related to Fire in Huai Nan Zi Di Xing Xun, and "Chi Di Zi kills Bai Di Zi" are all later interpolations and are, therefore, unconvincing. The author offers ten questions conflicting with the old sayings.
本文认为,所有这些材料,包括《吕氏春秋·十二纪》的第一章、《淮南子·地形训》中的“心与火相关”理论以及“赤帝子杀白帝子”等,都是后来添加的内容,因此不足为信。作者提出了十个与旧说相矛盾的问题。