Wang S, Pang S
Zhonghua Yi Shi Za Zhi. 1995 Jan;25(1):46-51.
Careful investigation on three different ancient editions of On Five Viscera reveals that all the following editions, viz. the latter parts of A and C edition of Zhang Zhongjing's On Five Viscera, Treating humankind of classified collectics of recipes, are ancient editions of Zhang Zhongjing's On Five Viscera which are derived from a common source edition. Since the contents of Zhang Zhongjing's and Jiva's On Five Viscera are basically the same; they are all apocryphal books. This paper also summarizes the achievements of these three books, including macrocosm-microcosm unison, anatomy, three-segment theory of human body, acupoints, and herbology.
对三种不同的古代《五脏论》版本进行仔细研究后发现,以下所有版本,即张仲景《五脏论》A版和C版的后半部分、《类聚方》中的《五脏论》,都是源自同一母本的张仲景《五脏论》古代版本。由于张仲景的《五脏论》与耆婆的《五脏论》内容基本相同,它们都是伪书。本文还总结了这三本书的成就,包括天人合一、解剖学、人体三段论、穴位和本草学。