Cánovas B, Ruperto M, Mendoza E, Koning M A, Martín E, Segurola H, Garriga M, Vázquez C
Unidad de Nutrición Clínica, Hospital de Ramón y Cajal, Madrid, España.
Nutr Hosp. 2001 Jul-Aug;16(4):116-20.
To assess the concordance between corporal self-perception and BMI calculated in a population of volunteers.
to know the percentage of overweight, normoweight and obese individuals in this population.
The study includes 160 volunteers recruited at the Gómez Ulla and Severo Ochoa Hospitals in Madrid during the 4th edition of the "Obesity Day".
A total of 160 interviews were carried out, comprising a first group of 10 questions about how obesity is understood, how they classify themselves by self-perception (obese, overweight or normoweight individuals), the incidence of obesity in the family, living habits and the number of previous failed attempts to lose weight. In the case of a positive response to the last question, the survey is extended to 19 questions, analyzing the reasons, prescriptors, methods used, and weight loss results obtained.
The mean Body Mass Index (BMI) of the interviewees was 26.2 +/- 4.97 kg/m2, with 27.45 +/- 5.4 kg/m2 for males and 25.76 +/- 4.7 kg/m2 for women. Overweight men represented 32.5%, with 27.3% overweight women, while obese men accounted for 25.6% and obese women amounted to 20.6%. The differences were not significant between sexes, normoweight, overweight and obesity groups. The concordance between self-perception and BMI using the kappa index was 0,464 for the total sample, 0.229 for males and 0.527 for women, and according to the valuation scale proposed by Landis and Koch, it would correspond to a moderate degree of agreement for the population in general, medium for men and moderate for women.
Overweight and obesity affect a high percentage of the Spanish population (almost 50%). Women show greater concern about being overweight, are more likely to participate in prevention campaigns, and present a corporal perception more in line with their true weight. Preventive campaigns should be implemented to reach the male population better, taking into account that this population presents a greater cardiovascular risk. It is important to place the problem of obesity in the right terms, without any "obesophobia" leading to disorders of the eating behaviour, while indicating the importance of the risk attributable to obesity and excess weight.
评估志愿者群体中身体自我认知与计算得出的体重指数(BMI)之间的一致性。
了解该群体中超重、体重正常和肥胖个体的百分比。
本研究纳入了在马德里的戈麦斯·乌拉医院和塞韦罗·奥乔亚医院第四届“肥胖日”期间招募的160名志愿者。
共进行了160次访谈,第一组包括10个问题,涉及对肥胖的理解、他们如何通过自我认知进行分类(肥胖、超重或体重正常个体)、家族中肥胖的发生率、生活习惯以及之前减肥失败的次数。如果对最后一个问题的回答为肯定,则将调查扩展至19个问题,分析原因、开处方者、使用的方法以及获得的减肥结果。
受访者的平均体重指数(BMI)为26.2±4.97kg/m²,男性为27.45±5.4kg/m²,女性为25.76±4.7kg/m²。超重男性占32.5%,超重女性占27.3%,肥胖男性占25.6%,肥胖女性占20.6%。在性别、体重正常、超重和肥胖组之间差异不显著。使用kappa指数,总样本中自我认知与BMI之间的一致性为0.464,男性为0.229,女性为0.527,根据兰迪斯和科赫提出的评估量表,总体人群对应中等程度的一致性,男性为中等,女性为中等。
超重和肥胖影响了很大比例的西班牙人口(近50%)。女性对超重更为关注,更有可能参与预防活动,并且身体认知与实际体重更相符。应开展预防活动以更好地覆盖男性人群,因为该人群存在更大的心血管风险。以正确的方式看待肥胖问题很重要,避免任何“肥胖恐惧症”导致饮食行为紊乱,同时指出肥胖和超重带来的风险的重要性。