Simmons P, Hoar A
Department of Psychiatry, Royal Free Hospital, London.
Med Sci Law. 2001 Oct;41(4):342-8. doi: 10.1177/002580240104100412.
A retrospective one-year study of the use of Section 136 of the Mental Health Act was undertaken in Haringey between 1995 and 1996 to ascertain behaviours resulting in detention, and their admission rate. Data were extracted from police Section 136 forms, Emergency Assessment Centre records and patient notes. Of 90 people assessed under Section 136, the majority were male and lived locally, with the largest ethnic group being Afro-Caribbean. Each category of presenting behaviour recorded by the police was a high predictor of admission, with an overall admission rate of 82%. Behavioural categories with an admission rate of less than 79% were threats or acts of deliberate self-harm and 'confusion' or disorientation (57% and 67% admission rates), which both warrant police referral for specialized assessment. The three most common presenting behaviours were violent threats/acts, abnormal form or stream of speech, and walking/lying/running in the road. The police did not appear to over use Section 136. Section 136 data were incomplete, in keeping with previous studies. This should be rectified by the introduction of both a national data collection standard and a requirement for a defined local data collection point for all instances of Section 136.
1995年至1996年间,在哈林盖区进行了一项为期一年的回顾性研究,以了解根据《精神健康法》第136条进行拘留的行为及其收治率。数据取自警方的第136条表格、紧急评估中心记录和患者病历。在根据第136条接受评估的90人中,大多数为男性且居住在当地,最大的种族群体是非洲加勒比人。警方记录的每一类呈现行为都是收治的高度预测指标,总体收治率为82%。收治率低于79%的行为类别是威胁或故意自残行为以及“困惑”或定向障碍(收治率分别为57%和67%),这两种情况都需要警方转介进行专门评估。三种最常见的呈现行为是暴力威胁/行为、言语形式或语流异常以及在路上行走/躺卧/奔跑。警方似乎没有过度使用第136条。与之前的研究一致,第136条的数据不完整。这应通过引入国家数据收集标准以及要求为所有第136条案例设立明确的本地数据收集点来加以纠正。