Reid R, Kulkarni M, Beasley S
Department of Surgery, Christchurch Hospital.
N Z Med J. 2001 Oct 12;114(1141):441-3.
To review the experience in the South Island to predict the extent to which the outcome in intussusception might be expected to improve by the introduction of management guidelines and access to a regional specialist paediatric surgical service.
Children with intussusception treated in the South Island during an eleven year period until 1998 were identified from hospital coding systems, the Southern RegionalHealth Authority and from departmental audit programmes. Details of management and outcome were analysed.
Data proved difficult to obtain. There were 83 children identified with intussusception confirmed on enema or at surgery; 76 had an enema that was successful in 44. Delayed repeat enema and gas enema techniques were not used as frequently as might be expected. The operative rate was higher than that reported by other centres.
Current data, coding and audit systems have significant short comings, which limit availability of reliable outcome data. Increased awareness of the expanded indications for enema reduction, use of air (rather than barium) and delayed repeat enemas, and access to specialist paediatric surgical involvement appears to increase the nonoperative rate. Implementation of guidelines for the management of intussusception might be expected to reduce by more than half the number of children undergoing surgery for this condition in the South Island.
回顾南岛地区的经验,以预测引入管理指南和获得区域专科儿科手术服务后肠套叠治疗效果可能改善的程度。
通过医院编码系统、南岛地区卫生局和部门审计程序,确定了截至1998年的11年间在南岛接受治疗的肠套叠患儿。分析了管理和治疗结果的详细情况。
数据获取困难。共确定83例经灌肠或手术确诊为肠套叠的患儿;76例接受了灌肠治疗,其中44例成功。延迟重复灌肠和气灌肠技术的使用频率低于预期。手术率高于其他中心报告的水平。
当前的数据、编码和审计系统存在重大缺陷,限制了可靠治疗结果数据的可用性。提高对灌肠复位扩大适应症、使用空气(而非钡剂)和延迟重复灌肠的认识,以及获得专科儿科手术干预,似乎可提高非手术率。预计实施肠套叠管理指南可使南岛因该病接受手术的儿童数量减少一半以上。