Tilling K, Sterne J A, Rudd A G, Glass T A, Wityk R J, Wolfe C D
Department of Public Health Sciences, King's College London, London, UK.
Stroke. 2001 Dec 1;32(12):2867-73. doi: 10.1161/hs1201.099413.
Several prognostic factors have been identified for outcome after stroke. However, there is a need for empirically derived models that can predict outcome and assist in medical management during rehabilitation. To be useful, these models should take into account early changes in recovery and individual patient characteristics. We present such a model and demonstrate its clinical utility.
Data on functional recovery (Barthel Index) at 0, 2, 4, 6, and 12 months after stroke were collected prospectively for 299 stroke patients at 2 London hospitals. Multilevel models were used to model recovery trajectories, allowing for day-to-day and between-patient variation. The predictive performance of the model was validated with an independent cohort of 710 stroke patients.
Urinary incontinence, sex, prestroke disability, and dysarthria affected the level of outcome after stroke; age, dysphasia, and limb deficit also affected the rate of recovery. Applying this to the validation cohort, the average difference between predicted and observed Barthel Index was -0.4, with 90% limits of agreement from -7 to 6. Predicted Barthel Index lay within 3 points of the observed Barthel Index on 49% of occasions and improved to 69% when patients' recovery histories were taken into account.
The model predicts recovery at various stages of rehabilitation in ways that could improve clinical decision making. Predictions can be altered in light of observed recovery. This model is a potentially useful tool for comparing individual patients with average recovery trajectories. Patients at elevated risk could be identified and interventions initiated.
已确定了几种与卒中后预后相关的因素。然而,需要基于经验得出的模型,以预测预后并在康复期间辅助医疗管理。为了实用,这些模型应考虑恢复过程中的早期变化以及个体患者特征。我们提出了这样一个模型并展示了其临床实用性。
前瞻性收集了伦敦两家医院299例卒中患者在卒中后0、2、4、6和12个月时的功能恢复数据(巴氏指数)。采用多水平模型对恢复轨迹进行建模,以考虑每日变化和患者间差异。该模型的预测性能在一个由710例卒中患者组成的独立队列中得到验证。
尿失禁、性别、卒中前残疾和构音障碍影响卒中后的预后水平;年龄、失语和肢体缺陷也影响恢复速度。将此应用于验证队列,预测的和观察到的巴氏指数的平均差异为-0.4,90%的一致性界限为-7至6。预测的巴氏指数在49%的情况下与观察到的巴氏指数相差在3分以内,若考虑患者的恢复史,这一比例提高到69%。
该模型能够以改善临床决策的方式预测康复各阶段的恢复情况。可根据观察到的恢复情况调整预测。该模型是比较具有平均恢复轨迹的个体患者的潜在有用工具。可以识别出风险较高的患者并启动干预措施。