van de Mortel T, Bourke R, McLoughlin J, Nonu M, Reis M
School of Nursing and Health Care Practices, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW, Australia.
Am J Infect Control. 2001 Dec;29(6):395-9. doi: 10.1067/mic.2001.119511.
Nurses tend to wash their hands more often than physicians, and among nonhealth care workers, women tend to wash their hands more often than men. This study examined the influence of gender on the handwashing rates of health care workers (HCWs). The null hypotheses were that there would be no intergender difference in (a) handwashing rates in HCWs across professions and (b) within professional groups.
Handwashing by nurses, physicians, wardspersons, x-ray technicians, and physiotherapists after patient contact in a critical care unit (CCU) was determined through covert observation. The gender and profession of the subjects were recorded, but their identity was not.
Female CCU staff washed their hands significantly more often than did their male counterparts after patient contact (P =.0001). When the results were examined for the influence of profession on handwashing, significant intergender differences remained for physicians (P =.0468) and wardspersons (P =.0001). There was also a nonsignificant trend (P =.07) toward higher rates of handwashing among female x-ray technicians. There were no statistically significant intergender differences in handwashing rates among nurses (P =.7588) and physiotherapists.
It appears that gender may influence handwashing rates in HCWs in the CCU, although this difference appears to be modified in particular professional groups. Further research should examine factors that modify handwashing rates within professional groups and in settings other than the CCU.
护士洗手的频率往往高于医生,在非医护人员中,女性洗手的频率往往高于男性。本研究探讨了性别对医护人员(HCWs)洗手率的影响。无效假设为:(a)不同职业的医护人员洗手率不存在性别差异;(b)在各专业组内不存在性别差异。
通过隐蔽观察确定重症监护病房(CCU)中护士、医生、病房护理员、X光技师和物理治疗师在接触患者后的洗手情况。记录受试者的性别和职业,但不记录其身份。
CCU的女性工作人员在接触患者后洗手的频率明显高于男性同行(P = 0.0001)。在研究职业对洗手的影响时,医生(P = 0.0468)和病房护理员(P = 0.0001)仍存在显著的性别差异。女性X光技师的洗手率也有不显著的上升趋势(P = 0.07)。护士(P = 0.7588)和物理治疗师的洗手率在性别上无统计学显著差异。
性别似乎可能影响CCU中医护人员的洗手率,尽管这种差异在特定专业组中似乎有所改变。进一步的研究应探讨在专业组内以及CCU以外的环境中影响洗手率的因素。