Thavendran A, Vijayaragavan A, Rasaretnam R
Br J Surg. 1975 Sep;62(9):750-2. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800620920.
The value of selective surgery for abdominal stab wounds was assessed in a prospective study of 226 patients admitted over an 18-month period. Two died soon after admission and before operation, the indications for which were signs of peritoneal irritation or haemorrhage, evisceration of bowel and omental protrusion. Of the 226 patients, 113 were selected for immediate surgery, which was carried out within 3 hours of admission. There were 12 deaths (10-6 per cent). Of the 111 patients initially selected for observation, 47 (42-3 per cent) underwent delayed operation with 4 deaths (8-5 per cent), but in only 1 (2-1 per cent) of these patients could the delay have influenced the adverse result. There were no deaths in the 64 patients treated conservatively. The overall mortality rate of patients who were initially selected for observation was 3-9 per cent. One hundred and fifty patients underwent laparotomy, positive findings justifying operation being present in 134 (89 per cent). Six patients required thoractomy for concomitant thoracic injuries, including 2 patients who required cardiorraphy. Four other patients required combined thoracic and abdominal exploration. The selection of patients for either conservative or operative management was based entirely on clinical criteris; abdominal X-rays were not helpful in the early diagnosis of visceral lesions. The indications for operation were evident within 12 hours of admission in 156 of the 160 patients who were treated surgically. A substantial reduction in the incidence of 'negative laparotomy' can be made by this process of selection, and without an associated increase in the morbidity and mortality rates.
在一项对18个月内收治的226例患者进行的前瞻性研究中,评估了腹部刺伤选择性手术的价值。2例患者入院后不久且在手术前死亡,手术指征为腹膜刺激征或出血、肠管脱出和网膜突出。在这226例患者中,113例被选择立即手术,在入院后3小时内进行。有12例死亡(10.6%)。在最初选择观察的111例患者中,47例(42.3%)接受了延迟手术,有4例死亡(8.5%),但其中只有1例(2.1%)患者的延迟可能影响了不良结果。64例接受保守治疗的患者无死亡。最初选择观察的患者总体死亡率为3.9%。150例患者接受了剖腹手术,134例(89%)有阳性发现证明手术合理。6例患者因合并胸部损伤需要开胸手术,其中2例需要心脏修补术。另外4例患者需要进行胸腹联合探查。选择患者进行保守或手术治疗完全基于临床标准;腹部X线对内脏损伤的早期诊断无帮助。在接受手术治疗的160例患者中,156例在入院后12小时内手术指征明显。通过这种选择过程可以大幅降低“阴性剖腹手术”的发生率,且不会增加发病率和死亡率。