Chambers S T, Heckert K A, Bagshaw S, Ussher J, Birch M, Wilson M A
Department of Infectious Diseases, Christchurch Hospital.
N Z Med J. 2001 Nov 23;114(1144):513-6.
To assess current attitudes and practice toward antenatal human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) risk assessment, HIV testing and barriers towards implementation of these among midwives, general practitioners (GPs) and obstetricians in the upper South Island
A survey was conducted among maternity care providers by anonymous self-administered questionnaire. Most questions were dichotomous, forced choice or Likert scale format but there were four open- ended questions asking for a written response.
The response rate was 57% overall. The main finding was that 275 (66%) of respondents assessed risk of HIV in less than 10% of patients, and 328 (midwives 93, 85%; GP's 226,77%; obstetricians 9,64%) respondents had performed less than three HIV tests in the past twelve months. Most respondents strongly agreed that detection of HIV during pregnancy is beneficial to mother 318 (83%) and to baby 367 (96%) and to mother prior to pregnancy 353 (92%). 202 (52%) supported and 44 (11%) were opposed to an antenatal screening programme in New Zealand. Most knew how to assess risk for HIV saw themselves as having an important role in antenatal HIV testing, and were comfortable performing risk assessment. Multiple reasons for current practices were offered, including perceived reluctance by women to be tested, lack of time, skills, knowledge and support services, and low rates of HIV in the community.
The current policy of routine HIV risk assessment is not working among respondents. A systematic reassessment and implementation of a workable strategy needs to be undertaken in New Zealand.
评估南岛上部地区的助产士、全科医生(GP)和产科医生目前对产前人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)风险评估、HIV检测的态度及实践情况,以及实施这些工作的障碍。
通过匿名自填问卷对孕产妇护理提供者进行调查。大多数问题采用二分法、强制选择或李克特量表形式,但有四个开放式问题要求书面作答。
总体回复率为57%。主要发现是,275名(66%)受访者对不到10%的患者进行了HIV风险评估,328名受访者(助产士93名,占85%;全科医生226名,占77%;产科医生9名,占64%)在过去十二个月内进行的HIV检测少于三次。大多数受访者强烈同意孕期检测出HIV对母亲有益的有318名(83%),对婴儿有益的有367名(96%),对孕前母亲有益的有353名(92%)。202名(52%)支持,44名(11%)反对新西兰的产前筛查计划。大多数人知道如何评估HIV风险,认为自己在产前HIV检测中发挥着重要作用,并且对进行风险评估感到放心。对于当前的做法给出了多种原因,包括认为女性不愿意接受检测、缺乏时间、技能、知识和支持服务,以及社区中HIV感染率较低。
受访者中目前的常规HIV风险评估政策不起作用。新西兰需要对可行策略进行系统的重新评估和实施。