Marbella Anne M, Holloway Richard L, Sherwood Roger, Layde Peter M
Department of Family and Community Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee 53226-0509, USA.
Acad Med. 2002 Feb;77(2):173-6. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200202000-00018.
To examine academic rankings and educational backgrounds of underrepresented minority (URM) family medicine faculty and compare their academic ranks with national trends. The authors also determined the extent to which international and historically black educational institutions contributed URM faculty to family medicine.
In 1999 questionnaires were sent to 129 family medicine departments asking for academic ranks and educational institutions attended by their URM faculty. Comparisons were made between URM faculty's academic ranks and all family medicine faculty, medical school minority faculty, and medical school faculty.
A total of 80% of URM faculty were assistant professors or instructors, and 4.4% were professors. URM family medicine faculty had significantly lower rankings compared with medical school minority faculty and all family medicine faculty. URM family medicine faculty at historically black medical schools were more likely to have received their degrees from historically black undergraduate institutions and medical schools than were URM family medicine faculty at non-historically-black medical schools.
URM family medicine faculty appear to experience a double disadvantage: being minority and working for family medicine departments. Their academic ranks remain far below those of both minority medical school faculty and family medicine faculty, a discouraging finding considering the current shortage of URM faculty in family medicine departments. Historically black medical schools cannot address the shortage alone, so non-historically-black medical schools need to both recruit URM faculty and follow up with appropriate mentoring of those faculty.
研究未被充分代表的少数族裔(URM)家庭医学教员的学术排名和教育背景,并将他们的学术排名与全国趋势进行比较。作者还确定了国际和历史悠久的黑人教育机构为家庭医学贡献URM教员的程度。
1999年,向129个家庭医学系发送了问卷,询问其URM教员的学术排名和就读的教育机构。对URM教员的学术排名与所有家庭医学教员、医学院少数族裔教员和医学院教员进行了比较。
共有80%的URM教员为助理教授或讲师,4.4%为教授。与医学院少数族裔教员和所有家庭医学教员相比,URM家庭医学教员的排名显著较低。与非历史悠久的黑人医学院的URM家庭医学教员相比,历史悠久的黑人医学院的URM家庭医学教员更有可能从历史悠久的黑人本科院校和医学院获得学位。
URM家庭医学教员似乎面临双重劣势:既是少数族裔,又在家庭医学系工作。他们的学术排名仍远低于少数族裔医学院教员和家庭医学教员,考虑到目前家庭医学系URM教员短缺的情况,这一发现令人沮丧。历史悠久的黑人医学院无法单独解决短缺问题,因此非历史悠久的黑人医学院既需要招聘URM教员,又需要对这些教员进行适当的指导跟进。