Charles Y P, Axt M, Döderlein L
Clinique Orthopédique Universitaire de Heidelberg, 69118 Heidelberg, Allemagne.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2001 Nov;87(7):696-705.
Pes cavovarus is a complex deformity of the forefoot, the midfoot and the hindfoot, frequently of neuropathologic etiology. The goals of surgical interventions consist of anatomical and functional correction of the foot deformity by soft tissue and bony procedures. Preoperative planning and postoperative assessment are based on clinical and radiographic examination. The present study was undertaken to find out if pedobarographic outcomes correlate with those postoperative results and if the dynamic pedobarography provides useful information in the functional evaluation of cavovarus feet.
Sixteen patients with cavovarus foot deformity (mean age 32.8 years, range 17-56) with a total of 21 feet were examined before and after surgery. The average follow-up time was 24 months (range 6-50). The study protocol included physical examination, angle measurements on weightbearing radiographs and dynamic pedobarography. The patients performed five trials at self-selected speed for each foot. The amount of correlation was established between: plantar peak pressure pattern and patient's subjective functional result, the evidence of callosities and increased peak pressures in forefoot and midfoot regions of interest, the change of calcaneal pitch or Hibbs' angle (first metatarsal - calcaneal axis) and the midfoot contact area.
The patient's functional opinion and pedobarographic improvement of peak pressures correlated in 7 feet, the patients estimated the result better in 13 feet and worse in 1 foot. In 4 regions of interest callosities and increased peak pressures occurred together in 69% of the cases, in 15.5% callosities were observed without augmented peak pressures and in 15.5% increased peak pressures were measured without evidence of callosities. No correlation was found between radiographic and pedobarographic parameters which describe a reduction of the cavus deformity: calcaneal pitch angle and midfoot contact area (Pearson correlation coefficient r=- 0.36), Hibbs' angle and midfoot contact area (r=0.55), although all parameters changed significantly (p=0.001).
Pre- and postoperative assessment of the cavovarus foot is mainly based on static methods such as clinical and radiographic evaluation. The results of this study demonstrate that the dynamic measurement of plantar peak pressures and contact area offers limited information about functional and anatomical improvement after surgery. Patients with severe deformities and muscular discoordination have difficulties walking consistently on the platform at each trial and severe decrease of plantar contact area makes the exact positioning of the masks difficult, which leads to problems with standardised measurements. In this context, the dynamic pedobarography cannot be used as a profitable diagnostic tool which provides an objective measurement that can add a dynamic component to a clinical or radiographic examination.
高弓内翻足是一种涉及前足、中足和后足的复杂畸形,常由神经病理学病因引起。外科手术干预的目标是通过软组织和骨手术对足部畸形进行解剖学和功能性矫正。术前规划和术后评估基于临床和影像学检查。本研究旨在探究足底压力测量结果与术后结果是否相关,以及动态足底压力测量在高弓内翻足功能评估中是否能提供有用信息。
对16例高弓内翻足畸形患者(平均年龄32.8岁,范围17 - 56岁)共21只脚在手术前后进行了检查。平均随访时间为24个月(范围6 - 50个月)。研究方案包括体格检查、负重位X线片角度测量和动态足底压力测量。患者每只脚以自行选择的速度进行五次测试。确定了以下各项之间的相关程度:足底峰值压力模式与患者主观功能结果、前足和中足感兴趣区域胼胝体证据及峰值压力增加、跟骨倾斜度或希布斯角(第一跖骨 - 跟骨轴线)变化与中足接触面积。
7只脚患者的功能评价与足底压力测量峰值压力改善情况相关,13只脚患者估计结果较好,1只脚患者估计结果较差。在4个感兴趣区域,69%的病例胼胝体和峰值压力增加同时出现,15.5%的病例观察到有胼胝体但无峰值压力增加,15.5%的病例测量到峰值压力增加但无胼胝体证据。在描述高弓畸形减轻的影像学和足底压力测量参数之间未发现相关性:跟骨倾斜角与中足接触面积(皮尔逊相关系数r = - 0.36)、希布斯角与中足接触面积(r = 0.55),尽管所有参数均有显著变化(p = 0.001)。
高弓内翻足的术前和术后评估主要基于静态方法,如临床和影像学评估。本研究结果表明,动态测量足底峰值压力和接触面积在术后功能和解剖学改善方面提供的信息有限。严重畸形和肌肉不协调的患者在每次测试时难以在平台上持续行走,足底接触面积严重减小使得面罩的准确定位困难,这导致标准化测量出现问题。在此背景下,动态足底压力测量不能用作一种有益的诊断工具,无法提供可在临床或影像学检查中增加动态成分的客观测量。