Lewith G T, Hyland M, Gray S F
University of Southampton, UK.
Complement Ther Med. 2001 Sep;9(3):167-72. doi: 10.1054/ctim.2001.0475.
To evaluate the use of attitudes to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) among UK physicians.
Postal questionnaire.
All Members and Fellows of the Royal College of Physicians.
Twelve thousand, one hundred and sixty eight Members and Fellows were surveyed and a response rate of 23% (n = 2,875) was obtained. Responses from the small numbers of general practitioners (n = 127) were not included in the analyses, resulting in a sample size of 2,748: 79% of respondents were in NHS practice, 32% of respondents practised CAM themselves, and 41% referred patients to CAM; of those who referred patients, 78% referred between 0-3 patients per month. CAM is used by physicians more frequently in private as compared to NHS practice. Acupuncture, aromatherapy and manipulative medicine (osteopathy and chiropractic) are the most commonly referred to and the most commonly practised therapies. Eighty seven percent of those using CAM themselves, or as part of their clinical team's commitment, had not had any CAM training. Attitudes to CAM were generally positive, particularly among those in palliative care, rehabilitation, nuclear medicine, and genito-urinary medicine.
Our conclusions must be tempered by the limited response rate, but assuming all non-responders were disinterested in CAM, then at least one in ten UK specialist physicians are actively involved in CAM treatments, although only 13% of our sample had received any CAM training.
评估英国医生对补充和替代医学(CAM)的态度。
邮寄问卷调查。
皇家内科医学院所有成员和院士。
对12168名成员和院士进行了调查,得到了23%(n = 2875)的回复率。少量全科医生(n = 127)的回复未纳入分析,最终样本量为2748:79%的受访者在国民健康服务体系(NHS)工作,32%的受访者自己使用补充和替代医学,41%的受访者会将患者转介至补充和替代医学领域;在那些转介患者的人中,78%每月转介0至3名患者。与在国民健康服务体系工作相比,医生在私人执业中更频繁地使用补充和替代医学。针灸、芳香疗法和手法医学(整骨疗法和脊椎按摩疗法)是最常被提及和最常应用的疗法。87%自己使用补充和替代医学或作为其临床团队工作一部分的人没有接受过任何补充和替代医学培训。对补充和替代医学的态度总体上是积极的,尤其是在姑息治疗、康复、核医学和泌尿生殖医学领域的医生中。
由于回复率有限,我们的结论必须谨慎对待,但假设所有未回复者对补充和替代医学不感兴趣,那么至少十分之一的英国专科医生积极参与补充和替代医学治疗,尽管我们样本中只有13%的人接受过任何补充和替代医学培训。