McKay James R, Donovan Dennis M, McLellan Thomas, Krupski Antoinette, Hansten Michelle, Stark Kenneth D, Geary Kathy, Cecere Jarrod
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, USA.
Am J Drug Alcohol Abuse. 2002;28(2):307-38. doi: 10.1081/ada-120002976.
This study evaluated the relative effectiveness of two forms of publicly funded substance abuse treatment provided in Washington State: The full continuum (FC), in which clients receive approximately three weeks of inpatient treatment prior to outpatient care, and the partial continuum (PC), in which clients are admitted directly to outpatient treatment. Data on treatment process/proximal outcomes, such as psychological distress and readiness to change, were assessed at 8 weeks post intake, and data on treatment services received were obtained at 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Multidimensional outcomes, including alcohol and drug use as well as a number of psychosocial functioning outcomes, were assessed at 3 and 9 months post intake. Results indicated that clients in the FC had greater alcohol, drug, and legal problem severity at intake than those in the PC, whereas medical and employment problem severity was greater in the PC. Clients in the FC received more treatment services in the first 2 weeks than those in the PC, but there were no differences at subsequent points. Outcome analyses at 3 and 9 months indicated that clients in the FC had greater improvements in alcohol, drug, and psychiatric severity than those in the PC. Matching analyses indicated that clients with greater substance-use severity at baseline improved to a greater degree in the FC as compared to the PC. Matching effects were not obtained with medical or psychiatric severity, or readiness to change.
全程连续治疗(FC),即患者在接受门诊治疗前先接受约三周的住院治疗;部分连续治疗(PC),即患者直接接受门诊治疗。在入院后8周评估治疗过程/近端结果的数据,如心理困扰和改变意愿,并在第2、4、8和12周获取接受治疗服务的数据。在入院后3个月和9个月评估多维结果,包括酒精和药物使用以及一些心理社会功能结果。结果表明,FC组患者入院时的酒精、药物和法律问题严重程度高于PC组,而PC组的医疗和就业问题严重程度更高。FC组患者在最初2周内接受的治疗服务比PC组更多,但在后续时间点没有差异。3个月和9个月时的结果分析表明,FC组患者在酒精、药物和精神疾病严重程度方面的改善比PC组更大。匹配分析表明,与PC组相比,基线时药物使用严重程度较高的患者在FC组中的改善程度更大。在医疗或精神疾病严重程度或改变意愿方面未获得匹配效应。