Skelly Chris, Black Wendy, Hearnden Mark, Eyles Rebekah, Weinstein Phil
Public Health Intelligence Group, Public Health Directorate, Ministry of Health, Wellington, New Zealand.
Aust J Rural Health. 2002 Apr;10(2):87-93.
This study illustrates the impact of address geocoding uncertainty on rural estimates of reportable disease incidence using campylobacteriosis as an example. After all cases of campylobacteriosis notified from 1993 to 1997 had been geocoded, the minimum and maximum disease notification rates were calculated for rural and urban areas of New Zealand. The estimated maximum rural rates were four times higher than estimated minimum rural rates, whereas estimated minimum and maximum urban rates varied minimally. The impact of address geocoding on the estimation of disease notification rates across Public Health Service Regions showed considerable variation. The relative proportions of ungeocoded notifications to rural notifications ranged from 1.3:1 to 10.2:1, reflecting the range of uncertainty in estimated rural rates of campylobacteriosis. Unless the reliability of captured rural address data is improved significantly, disease surveillance systems will underestimate rural rates of disease and limit small area analyses.
本研究以弯曲杆菌病为例,阐述了地址地理编码不确定性对农村地区法定传染病发病率估计的影响。在对1993年至1997年报告的所有弯曲杆菌病病例进行地理编码后,计算了新西兰农村和城市地区的最低和最高疾病报告率。估计的农村最高发病率是农村最低发病率的四倍,而估计的城市最低和最高发病率变化极小。地址地理编码对公共卫生服务区疾病报告率估计的影响差异很大。未进行地理编码的报告与农村报告的相对比例在1.3:1至10.2:1之间,反映了弯曲杆菌病农村发病率估计的不确定性范围。除非显著提高所采集农村地址数据的可靠性,疾病监测系统将低估农村疾病发病率,并限制小区域分析。