Jacobsen Paul B, Meade Cathy D, Stein Kevin D, Chirikos Thomas N, Small Brent J, Ruckdeschel John C
H. Lee Moffitt Cancer Center and Research Institute and University of South Florida, Tampa, FL 33612, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2002 Jun 15;20(12):2851-62. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2002.08.301.
Professionally administered psychosocial interventions have been shown to improve the quality of life of cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy. The present study sought to improve access to psychosocial interventions during chemotherapy treatment by evaluating the efficacy and costs of a patient self-administered form of stress management training that requires limited professional time or experience to deliver.
Four hundred eleven patients about to start chemotherapy were randomly assigned to receive usual psychosocial care only, a professionally administered form of stress management training, or a patient self-administered form of stress management training. Quality-of-life assessments were conducted before randomization and before the second, third, and fourth treatment cycles. Intervention costs were estimated from both payer and societal perspectives.
Compared with patients who received usual care only, patients receiving the self-administered intervention reported significantly (P < or = .05) better physical functioning, greater vitality, fewer role limitations because of emotional problems, and better mental health. In contrast, patients who received the professionally administered intervention fared no better in terms of quality of life than patients receiving usual care only. Costs of the self-administered intervention were estimated to be 66% (from a payer perspective) to 68% (from a societal perspective) less than the average costs of professionally administered psychosocial interventions for patients starting chemotherapy.
Evidence regarding the efficacy and favorable costs of self-administered stress management training suggests that this intervention has the potential to greatly improve patient access to psychosocial intervention during chemotherapy treatment.
专业实施的心理社会干预已被证明可改善接受化疗的癌症患者的生活质量。本研究旨在通过评估一种患者自我实施的压力管理培训形式的疗效和成本,来改善化疗治疗期间心理社会干预的可及性,这种培训形式所需的专业时间或经验有限。
411名即将开始化疗的患者被随机分配,分别接受仅常规心理社会护理、专业实施的压力管理培训或患者自我实施的压力管理培训。在随机分组前以及在第二个、第三个和第四个治疗周期前进行生活质量评估。从支付方和社会角度估计干预成本。
与仅接受常规护理的患者相比,接受自我实施干预的患者在身体功能、活力、因情绪问题导致的角色限制更少以及心理健康方面的报告有显著(P≤0.05)改善。相比之下,接受专业实施干预的患者在生活质量方面并不比仅接受常规护理的患者更好。自我实施干预的成本估计比开始化疗患者专业实施心理社会干预的平均成本低66%(从支付方角度)至68%(从社会角度)。
关于自我实施压力管理培训的疗效和有利成本的证据表明,这种干预有可能在化疗治疗期间极大地改善患者获得心理社会干预的机会。