Hakko Helinä, Räsänen Pirkko, Tiihonen Jari, Nieminen Pentti
Department of Psychiatry at the University of Oulu, Finland.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2002 Summer;32(2):191-208. doi: 10.1521/suli.32.2.191.24403.
The effect of seasons on suicides has been suggested repeatedly. In order to reveal a true seasonal pattern, an appropriate statistical technique, which is sensitive to a specific type of cyclic variation in the data, must be chosen. This study is a review of the use of statistical techniques for seasonality and of some important characteristics of study samples that were evaluated from 46 original suicide seasonality articles published in major psychiatric journals. The results showed that statistical techniques were applied in a majority of articles, but they were commonly lacking regarding analyses, which compared seasonal patterns among subgroups of a population. In recent studies more sophisticated statistical techniques were utilized for seasonality, like spectral analyses, as compared with earlier studies, in which the emphasis was on chi-square tests. Lack of reporting essential features of the data, such as the sample size and monthly values of suicides, were frequent. The calendar effect was adjusted only in 11 studies. Some recommendations concerning the methodological and reporting issues are summarized for future articles on the seasonal affect on suicides.
季节对自杀的影响已被多次提及。为了揭示真实的季节性模式,必须选择一种对数据中特定类型的周期性变化敏感的合适统计技术。本研究回顾了用于季节性分析的统计技术以及从主要精神病学期刊上发表的46篇关于自杀季节性的原始文章中评估的研究样本的一些重要特征。结果表明,大多数文章都应用了统计技术,但在分析方面普遍存在不足,即未对人群亚组之间的季节性模式进行比较。与早期研究相比,近期研究在季节性分析中采用了更复杂的统计技术,如频谱分析,早期研究则侧重于卡方检验。经常出现未报告数据基本特征的情况,如样本量和每月自杀人数。仅在11项研究中对日历效应进行了调整。针对未来关于季节对自杀影响的文章,总结了一些关于方法学和报告问题的建议。