Lofgren Don J
WISHA Services, Department of Labor and Industries, State of Washington, Tacoma, USA.
Appl Occup Environ Hyg. 2002 Jul;17(7):501-11. doi: 10.1080/10473220290035741.
Occupational exposure to carbon monoxide continues to cause a number of injuries and deaths. This study reviewed the State of Washington OSHA inspection records for occupational safety or health violations related to carbon monoxide for the time period 1994-1999 to assess the agency's efforts and further identify and characterize causative factors. Inspection data were also compared with carbon monoxide claims data from a companion study to determine if the agency was visiting the most at risk work operations. Inspections were identified by searching computerized violation texts for "carbon monoxide" or "CO." The study found 142 inspections with one or more carbon monoxide violations. Inspections were spread over 84 different 4-digit Standard Industrial Classification codes. Most inspections were initiated as a result of a complaint or other informant. Inspections were predominantly in construction and manufacturing, whereas carbon monoxide claims were mores evenly distributed between the major industries. Inspections also may have failed to find violations for some types of equipment responsible for carbon monoxide claims. Forklifts were the source of carbon monoxide most often associated with a violation, followed by compressors for respirators, auto/truck/bus, and temporary heating devices. Inspections in response to poisonings found common factors associated with lack of recognition and failure to use or maintain equipment and ventilation. Some work sites with one or more poisonings were not being inspected. Only 10 of the 51 incidents with industrial insurance claim reports of carboxyhemoglobin at or above 20 percent were inspected. Further, it was found more preventive efforts should be targeted at cold storage operations and certain warehouse and construction activities. It is proposed that more specific standards, both consensus and regulatory, would provide additional risk reduction. Reliance upon safe work practices as a primary method of control in the use of fuel-powered equipment in cold storage or other enclosed and unventilated environments needs to be prohibited. The study further demonstrates how inspection and industrial insurance records can assist with preventive efforts and better focus an agency's efforts.
职业接触一氧化碳持续导致大量人员伤亡。本研究回顾了华盛顿州职业安全与健康管理局(OSHA)1994 - 1999年期间与一氧化碳相关的职业安全或健康违规检查记录,以评估该机构的工作成效,并进一步识别和描述致病因素。检查数据还与一项配套研究中的一氧化碳索赔数据进行了比较,以确定该机构是否对风险最高的作业进行了检查。通过在计算机化的违规文本中搜索“一氧化碳”或“CO”来识别检查记录。该研究发现了142次存在一项或多项一氧化碳违规的检查。检查涉及84个不同的4位数标准产业分类代码。大多数检查是因投诉或其他举报人而发起的。检查主要集中在建筑和制造业,而一氧化碳索赔在主要行业之间分布更为均匀。检查可能也未能发现一些导致一氧化碳索赔的设备类型存在的违规行为。叉车是最常与违规相关的一氧化碳来源,其次是呼吸器压缩机、汽车/卡车/公交车以及临时加热设备。针对中毒事件的检查发现了与缺乏认知以及未使用或维护设备及通风相关的常见因素。一些发生过一起或多起中毒事件的工作场所未接受检查。在51起工业保险索赔报告中,碳氧血红蛋白含量达到或超过20%的事件中,只有10起接受了检查。此外,研究发现应将更多预防措施针对冷藏作业以及某些仓库和建筑活动。建议制定更具体的共识性和监管性标准,以进一步降低风险。在冷藏或其他封闭且通风不良的环境中,使用燃油动力设备时,应禁止将安全工作规范作为主要控制方法。该研究进一步证明了检查记录和工业保险记录如何有助于预防工作,并更好地集中机构的工作重点。