Chantelot C, Feugas C, Ala Eddine T, Migaud H, Gueguen G, Fontaine C
Service d'Orthopédie-Traumatologie B, Hôpital B, CHRU de Lille, place de Verdun, 59037 Lille Cedex.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2002 Jun;88(4):398-405.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: We analyzed retrospectively 30 Kudo non-constrained elbow prostheses to determine: 1) functional outcome and mobility, 2) frequency of loosening and any complications. MATERIAL AND METHODS: From 1992 to 1998, 30 Kudo total elbow arthroplasties were performed in 29 patients, mean age 55 years. Mean follow-up was 36 months. These patients had severe joint disease: rheumatoid arthritis for 24, psoriatic arthritis for 2, and hemophilic arthritis for 3. The 29 patients experienced severe pain before surgery. RESULTS: At review, 21 elbows were pain free and the 9 others had only occasional pain. Among these 9 elbows, 3 exhibited a rupture of the humeral implant; one had already been revised but remained painful. One patient had a stiff painful elbow after reflex dystrophy and five others had pain but no other complication. Twenty-six patients were satisfied or very satisfied. Three patients were unsatisfied because of the humeral implant fracture. Mean mobility at last follow-up was: 128 degrees flexion, -35 degrees extension, 72 degrees pronation, and 74 degrees supination. Mean gain in flexion-extension was 15 degrees and mean gain in pronosupination was 3 degrees. Pronosupination was greater than 100 degrees except for two patients. There was one immediate post-operative dislocation with failure of prolonged orthopedic treatment after reduction; this patient underwent revision reconstruction with repair of the ulnar collateral ligaments (plasty of the medial collateral ligament with a synthetic ligament). Painful movement of the radial stump was observed with one Kudo prosthesis and required resection to achieve cure. In all, there were 3 fractures of the Kudo I prosthesis at the junction of the trochlea and the humeral stem. Among these patients, one underwent revision due to persistent pain, and two others with currently acceptable symptoms are awaiting revision. At last follow-up, we had: 1 ulnar loosening associated with cortical thinning facing the end of the ulnar implant that had migrated and showed a circular lucent line measuring > 1 mm and progressing; 9 unique ulnar lucent lines measuring<1 mm without progression at the proximal part of the implant (6 at the bone-cement interface and 3 at the bone-implant interface); 3 humeral radiolucent lines (<1 mm without progression) on the distal part of the Kudo II humeral stems corresponding to a zone without surfacing. We also observed 13 cases of incomplete ossification between the humerus and ulna and among these 13, 7 elbows had amplitudes of less than 100 degrees. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Elbow arthroplasty can restore a painless joint and maintain or improve elbow motion. The procedure is indicated when the joint disease impair daily life activities. Final mobility basically depends on the preoperative mobility. The bone stock remains the greatest problem with these resurfaced prostheses. The GUEPAR elbow prosthesis would appear to be more adapted due to the reconstruction of the trochlea. Resection of the radial head is a source of instability for elbow prostheses and should lead to the design of three-compartment prostheses.
研究目的:我们回顾性分析了30例Kudo非限制性肘关节假体,以确定:1)功能结果和活动度;2)松动频率及任何并发症。 材料与方法:1992年至1998年,对29例患者实施了30例Kudo全肘关节置换术,平均年龄55岁。平均随访时间为36个月。这些患者患有严重的关节疾病:类风湿关节炎24例,银屑病关节炎2例,血友病性关节炎3例。这29例患者术前均有严重疼痛。 结果:复查时,21例肘关节无痛,另外9例仅有偶尔疼痛。在这9例肘关节中,3例肱骨假体出现破裂;其中1例已经翻修但仍疼痛。1例患者在反射性交感神经营养不良后出现肘关节僵硬疼痛,另外5例有疼痛但无其他并发症。26例患者满意或非常满意。3例患者因肱骨假体骨折不满意。末次随访时的平均活动度为:屈曲128度,伸展-35度,旋前72度,旋后74度。屈伸平均增加15度,旋前旋后平均增加3度。除2例患者外,旋前旋后均大于100度。术后立即发生1例脱位,复位后长期骨科治疗失败;该患者接受了翻修重建,修复了尺侧副韧带(用合成韧带行内侧副韧带成形术)。1例Kudo假体出现桡骨残端疼痛性活动,需要切除才能治愈。总共,Kudo I假体在滑车与肱骨干交界处发生3例骨折。在这些患者中,1例因持续疼痛接受了翻修,另外2例目前症状可接受,正在等待翻修。末次随访时,我们发现:1例尺侧松动,与尺骨假体末端相对的皮质变薄有关,假体已移位,出现一条宽度>1mm且仍在进展的圆形透亮线;9条独特的尺骨透亮线,宽度<1mm,位于假体近端且无进展(6条在骨水泥界面,3条在骨-假体界面);3条肱骨透亮线(宽度<1mm且无进展),位于Kudo II肱骨干远端对应无表面涂层的区域。我们还观察到13例肱骨与尺骨之间骨化不完全的病例,在这13例中,7例肘关节活动幅度小于100度。 讨论与结论:肘关节置换术可恢复无痛关节并维持或改善肘关节活动。当关节疾病影响日常生活活动时,该手术是适用的。最终活动度基本取决于术前活动度。对于这些表面置换假体,骨量仍然是最大的问题。由于滑车的重建,GUEPAR肘关节假体似乎更适用。桡骨头切除是肘关节假体不稳定的一个原因,应促使设计三室假体。
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2002-6
Ann Chir Main Memb Super. 1997
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2010-10
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004-3
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2001-9
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2003-5
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2011
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005-3