Frisancho Velarde O, Contardo Zambrano C
Departamento de Enfermedades del Aparato Digestivo, Hospital Nacional Edgardo Rabagliati Martins, Perú.
Rev Gastroenterol Peru. 1996 Sep-Dec;16(3):222-7.
A prospective study evaluated and compared midazolam versus diazepam in the upper gastrointestinal endoscopy. Patients were excluded if they had experienced any of the following: intolerance to benzodiazepines, pregnancy, alcohol or drug addiction, and weakness chronic disease. Seventy one patients were assigned to two groups: 36 received diazepam (0,15 Mg/Kg. intravenous) and 35 midazolam (0,07 mg/kg.). Patients in the two study group were similar in regard to demographic data (sex, age, and weight). Midazolam resulted in a marked improvement of conscious sedation and the anxiolysis as compared with the group receiving diazepam (p<0.001). Amnesia were significantly more frequent in the midazolam group (total 77,14% and partial 17,14%) compared with diazepam group (total 11,11% and partial 2,77%). The present study show that midazolam improves patient tolerance lo endoscopy compared with diazepam (p<0.001).The selection of patients is very important, no clinically adverse events related to cardiopulmonary changes ocurred in any group.
一项前瞻性研究对上消化道内镜检查中咪达唑仑与地西泮进行了评估和比较。如果患者有以下任何一种情况则被排除:对苯二氮䓬类药物不耐受、怀孕、酒精或药物成瘾以及患有慢性虚弱疾病。71名患者被分为两组:36名接受地西泮(0.15毫克/千克静脉注射),35名接受咪达唑仑(0.07毫克/千克)。两个研究组的患者在人口统计学数据(性别、年龄和体重)方面相似。与接受地西泮的组相比,咪达唑仑使清醒镇静和抗焦虑作用有显著改善(p<0.001)。与地西泮组(完全遗忘11.11%,部分遗忘2.77%)相比,咪达唑仑组的遗忘发生率显著更高(完全遗忘77.14%,部分遗忘17.14%)。本研究表明,与地西泮相比,咪达唑仑提高了患者对内镜检查的耐受性(p<0.001)。患者的选择非常重要,任何一组均未发生与心肺变化相关的临床不良事件。