Hruby G, Choo R, Jackson M, Warde P, Sandler H
Department of Radiation Oncology, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Australas Radiol. 2002 Sep;46(3):280-4. doi: 10.1046/j.1440-1673.2002.01060.x.
A survey to evaluate the preferred patterns of management of Stage I seminoma was conducted during March 2001. The questionnaire was distributed by the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Radiologists to all qualified radiation oncologists, 74 out of 170 responded. All performed a staging CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis. Thoracic imaging consisted of either chest X-ray (29%) or chest CT (38%) while 33% performed both. Fifty-four percent of radiation oncologists discussed surveillance with their patients but estimated that 5% or less would choose this option. The most commonly prescribed dose was 25 Gy in 15 or 20 fractions (79%). Sixty-five percent of respondents treated the para-aortic (PA) nodes alone. Forty-two of 48 clinicians treating the PA field reported a change in practice after publication of the Medical Research Council study in 1999. Of these, 40 and 23% perform CT scans of the pelvis annually and every 6 months. Thirty-one percent did no follow-up CT scan. Compared to a similar survey from North America, we are more likely to use PA fields and less likely to discuss surveillance. As in the USA, and in contrast to Canada, few patients choose surveillance. There is no consensus regarding the frequency of follow-up scans in either North America or Australasia.
2001年3月开展了一项评估I期精原细胞瘤首选治疗模式的调查。调查问卷由澳大利亚和新西兰皇家放射学会分发给所有合格的放射肿瘤学家,170人中有74人回复。所有人都进行了腹部和盆腔的分期CT扫描。胸部成像包括胸部X线检查(29%)或胸部CT(38%),33%的人同时进行了这两项检查。54%的放射肿瘤学家与患者讨论了监测方案,但估计只有5%或更少的患者会选择该方案。最常用的处方剂量是25 Gy,分15或20次给予(79%)。65%的受访者仅治疗腹主动脉旁(PA)淋巴结。在治疗PA区域的48名临床医生中,42人表示在1999年医学研究委员会的研究发表后改变了治疗方法。其中,40%和23%的人分别每年和每6个月进行一次盆腔CT扫描。31%的人未进行随访CT扫描。与北美类似的调查相比,我们更倾向于使用PA区域治疗,而较少讨论监测方案。与美国一样,与加拿大不同,很少有患者选择监测。在北美和澳大拉西亚,关于随访扫描的频率都没有达成共识。