Ross Gary E, Bever Frank N, Uddin Zi, Hockman Elaine M, Herman Benjamin A
St John Oakland Hospital, Madison Heights, Mich, USA.
J Am Osteopath Assoc. 2002 Aug;102(8):423-8.
The objectives of this study were to do inexpensive lamellar body count (LBC) in amniotic fluid, to do statistical analysis to evaluate cutoff values for fetal lung maturity (FLM) and fetal lung immaturity (FLI), to derive a threshold for obtaining a lecithin-to-sphingomyelin (L/S) ratio and phosphatidylglycerol percentage (%PG), and to determine the potential cost savings to the hospital if they use this new method. Testing (LBC, L/S ratio, and %PG) was done on 123 specimens of amniotic fluid. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve, discriminant, linear regression, chi2, and cost analyses were used to evaluate the laboratory and financial parameters. Lamellar body counts of greater than 41,500 (Coulter MAXM: sensitivity, 90.5%; specificity, 87.7%; positive predictive value, 79.2%; negative predictive value, 94.7%) and greater than 32,000 (Coulter Gen.S: sensitivity, 90.5%; specificity, 85.2%; positive predictive value, 76.0%; negative predictive value, 94.5%) were the best threshold for biochemical FLM. Similarly, LBC of less than 24,000 (MAXM: sensitivity, 78.6%; specificity, 100%; positive predictive value, 100%; negative predictive value, 90.0%) and less than 21,000 (Gen.S: sensitivity, 71.4%; specificity, 100%; positive predictive value, 100%; negative predictive value, 87.1%) provided the best statistical cutoff for biochemical FLI from discriminant analysis. The authors concluded that FLM and FLI can be predicted with reasonable accuracy from LBC in amniotic fluid specimens. The expensive and not easily accessible L/S ratio and %PG can then be done only in cases in which LBC indicates transitional FLM. A cascade approach results in 86% savings to the hospital if the L/S ratio and %PG are not sent to a reference laboratory.
本研究的目的是对羊水进行低成本的板层小体计数(LBC),进行统计分析以评估胎儿肺成熟(FLM)和胎儿肺不成熟(FLI)的临界值,得出获得卵磷脂与鞘磷脂(L/S)比值和磷脂酰甘油百分比(%PG)的阈值,并确定医院采用这种新方法可能节省的成本。对123份羊水样本进行了检测(LBC、L/S比值和%PG)。采用受试者操作特征(ROC)曲线、判别分析、线性回归、卡方检验和成本分析来评估实验室参数和财务参数。大于41,500的板层小体计数(库尔特MAXM:灵敏度,90.5%;特异性,87.7%;阳性预测值,79.2%;阴性预测值,94.7%)和大于32,000(库尔特Gen.S:灵敏度,90.5%;特异性,85.2%;阳性预测值,76.0%;阴性预测值,94.5%)是生化FLM的最佳阈值。同样,小于24,000的LBC(MAXM:灵敏度,78.6%;特异性,100%;阳性预测值,100%;阴性预测值,90.0%)和小于21,000(Gen.S:灵敏度,71.4%;特异性,100%;阳性预测值,100%;阴性预测值,87.1%)从判别分析中得出了生化FLI的最佳统计临界值。作者得出结论,通过羊水样本中的LBC可以合理准确地预测FLM和FLI。然后,只有在LBC表明处于过渡性FLM的情况下,才进行昂贵且不易获取的L/S比值和%PG检测。如果不将L/S比值和%PG送到参考实验室,采用级联方法可为医院节省86%的成本。