Marshall V R, Singh M, Tresidder G C, Blandy J P
Br J Urol. 1975;47(7):759-64. doi: 10.1111/j.1464-410x.1975.tb04054.x.
In 416 patients with renal and ureteric calculi other than large staghorns we found that when it was possible to identify the calyx of origin of the stones, the lower poles were involved in 36-6% of males and 40-4% of females. In the follow up of the 115 lower poles originally containing stones the recurrence rate was 17% in those who were merely observed, 56% in those treated by pyelo- or nephrolithotomy, and zero in those treated by partial neprectomy. But when these cases were looked at more closely it was found that recurrences were virtually confined to lower poles which had originally harboured more than one stone, while in those with single stones to start with, the recurrence rate was not significantly different in either of these three groups. Partial nephrectomy should therefore be reserved for selected cases where the stones are originally multiple, or where the lower pole has been severely damaged. It is not necessary for small and single calyceal calculi.
在416例非巨大鹿角形结石的肾和输尿管结石患者中,我们发现,当能够确定结石的起源肾盏时,男性下极受累的比例为36.6%,女性为40.4%。在最初有结石的115个下极的随访中,单纯观察的患者复发率为17%,肾盂或肾切开取石术治疗的患者复发率为56%,部分肾切除术治疗的患者复发率为零。但当更仔细地观察这些病例时,发现复发实际上局限于最初有不止一块结石的下极,而对于最初为单块结石的患者,这三组中的任何一组复发率均无显著差异。因此,部分肾切除术应保留用于结石最初为多发或下极已严重受损的特定病例。对于小的单发性肾盏结石则无此必要。