Ben-David Bruce
University of Pittsburgh, Department of Anesthesiology, A 1305 Scaife Hall, 3550 Terrace Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15261, USA.
Anesthesiol Clin North Am. 2002 Sep;20(3):665-667, ix. doi: 10.1016/s0889-8537(02)00003-2.
Perhaps the clearest picture of the numbers and types of injuries from regional anesthesia is provided by the ASA Closed Claims Project database. In reviewing these data, it is valuable to keep in mind, of course, that the lack of a denominator makes the calculation of incidence impossible. For the decade of the 1990s, 308 claims were associated with regional anesthesia (versus 642 claims associated with general anesthesia). The percentage of these claims for patient death (10%) continued its steady decline from more than 20% in the 1970s and 13% in the 1980s. The primary reason for death remains cardiac arrest associated with neuraxial blockade, though this now represents only 30% of the deaths as opposed to 61% in the 1970s and 40% in the 1980s. There were 71 permanent disabling injuries among the 308 claims. The most common of these (23%) was associated with nerve blocks of the eye (13 retrobulbar, 3 peribulbar), and typically the injury entailed loss of vision. Second in frequency (21%) were pain-management related claims involving, for example, neuraxial opiates or neurolytic blocks. Third in frequency (20%) were nerve injuries associated with neuraxial and peripheral blocks followed by epidural hematomas (13%).
美国麻醉医师协会(ASA)的封闭索赔项目数据库或许能最清晰地呈现区域麻醉所致损伤的数量及类型。在审视这些数据时,务必牢记,由于缺乏分母,发病率的计算是不可能的。在20世纪90年代的十年间,有308起索赔与区域麻醉相关(相比之下,与全身麻醉相关的索赔有642起)。这些索赔中患者死亡的比例(10%)从20世纪70年代的超过20%以及80年代的13%持续稳步下降。死亡的主要原因仍然是与神经轴阻滞相关的心脏骤停,不过如今这仅占死亡病例的30%,而在20世纪70年代为61%,80年代为40%。在308起索赔中有71起导致永久性致残损伤。其中最常见的(23%)与眼部神经阻滞相关(13例球后阻滞、3例球周阻滞),损伤通常导致视力丧失。频率第二高的(21%)是与疼痛管理相关的索赔,例如涉及神经轴阿片类药物或神经溶解阻滞。频率第三高的(20%)是与神经轴和周围阻滞相关的神经损伤,其次是硬膜外血肿(13%)。