Connolly Leonard P, Connolly Susan A, Drubach Laura A, Jaramillo Diego, Treves S Ted
Department of Radiology, Children's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts 02115, USA.
J Nucl Med. 2002 Oct;43(10):1310-6.
The emergence of MRI has challenged the long-standing primacy of skeletal scintigraphy in pediatric cases of suspected acute hematogenous osteomyelitis (AHO) with nondiagnostic radiographs. This study evaluated a strategy in which skeletal scintigraphy is the primary and MRI a supplemental test.
We reviewed the records of 213 children (age range, 8 mo-18 y; mean age, 67 mo) with musculoskeletal symptoms and nondiagnostic radiographs who were referred for skeletal scintigraphy because of the possibility of AHO. MRI was performed when diagnostic uncertainty persisted after skeletal scintigraphy or when abscess was suspected.
Diagnosis was made using skeletal scintigraphy without referral for MRI in 179 (84%) of the children, including 79 (92%) of 86 with a final diagnosis of AHO. In no instance was the diagnosis of AHO indicated only by MRI. Treatment and diagnosis were accomplished without referral for MRI in 146 (69%) of all cases and 46 (53%) of the AHO cases. Abscesses that required drainage were found in 3 (6%) of 48 cases of major-long-bone AHO. Each of these 3 had exhibited a slow therapeutic response before MRI. Drainable abscesses were found in 5 (20%) of 25 cases affecting the pelvis, which was the other preponderant location of AHO. These were found with pelvic foci both when MRI was performed at diagnosis and when MRI was performed during treatment.
An imaging strategy in which skeletal scintigraphy is the first test used when AHO is suspected but radiographs are negative remains highly effective. This approach can be most strongly advocated when symptoms are poorly localized or are localized to major long bones. MRI should be performed after skeletal scintigraphy shows major-long-bone AHO if treatment response is slow. Skeletal scintigraphy is also an appropriate first test for suspected radiographically occult pelvic AHO. Because of the association of abscesses with pelvic AHO, however, the use of MRI should be strongly considered after pelvic AHO is detected, and MRI might be substituted diagnostically for skeletal scintigraphy when symptoms are well localized to the pelvis.
磁共振成像(MRI)的出现挑战了骨骼闪烁扫描术在疑似急性血源性骨髓炎(AHO)且X线片无诊断价值的儿科病例中长期占据的首要地位。本研究评估了一种以骨骼闪烁扫描术为主、MRI为补充检查的策略。
我们回顾了213例有肌肉骨骼症状且X线片无诊断价值的儿童(年龄范围8个月至18岁;平均年龄67个月)的记录,这些儿童因可能患有AHO而被转诊进行骨骼闪烁扫描术。当骨骼闪烁扫描术后仍存在诊断不确定性或怀疑有脓肿时,则进行MRI检查。
179例(84%)儿童仅通过骨骼闪烁扫描术确诊,无需转诊进行MRI检查,其中最终诊断为AHO的86例中有79例(92%)。没有一例AHO仅通过MRI确诊。在所有病例中,146例(69%)以及AHO病例中的46例(53%)在未转诊进行MRI检查的情况下完成了治疗和诊断。在48例主要长骨AHO病例中,有3例(6%)发现了需要引流的脓肿。这3例在进行MRI检查前治疗反应均较慢。在25例累及骨盆的病例中,有5例(20%)发现了可引流的脓肿,骨盆是AHO的另一个主要发病部位。这些脓肿在诊断时进行MRI检查以及治疗期间进行MRI检查时均发现有骨盆病灶。
当怀疑AHO但X线片阴性时,首先使用骨骼闪烁扫描术的成像策略仍然非常有效。当症状定位不明确或局限于主要长骨时,这种方法最为可取。如果治疗反应缓慢,在骨骼闪烁扫描术显示主要长骨AHO后应进行MRI检查。对于疑似X线片隐匿性骨盆AHO,骨骼闪烁扫描术也是合适的首选检查。然而,由于脓肿与骨盆AHO相关,在检测到骨盆AHO后应强烈考虑使用MRI,并且当症状明确局限于骨盆时,MRI可替代骨骼闪烁扫描术进行诊断。