Bovier P A, Bock J, Loutan L, Farinelli T, Glueck R, Herzog C
Travel and Migration Medicine Unit, Department of Community Medicine Unit, Geneva University Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland.
J Med Virol. 2002 Dec;68(4):489-93. doi: 10.1002/jmv.10244.
The aim of this study was to predict the long-term protection induced after immunisation with inactivated, aluminium-free virosome hepatitis A vaccine. The study population consisted of adult volunteers enrolled in four different clinical trials. Lower 95% confidence interval limits and seroconversion rate were calculated by using a linear mixed model to estimate the persistence of serum antibodies over time. To assess the robustness of the mathematical model, several sensitivity analyses were performed with more conservative protective threshold (20 mIU/ml vs. 10 mIU/ml), higher yearly decline rate, and exclusion of volunteers who had increasing titres over time. Based on 190 volunteers with at least two valid assessments of titres from year 3 onward, the median duration of protection was 55.5 years, with a lower limit of the 95% CI of 48.7 years. Duration below 25.3 years was predicted for only 5% of the subjects. Women tended to have higher titres to start with, but their rate of decline was higher, resulting in similar duration of protection overall. The use of a more conservative threshold, higher yearly decline rate, and exclusion of volunteers with increasing titres over time did not affect these results. According to this model, 95% of the volunteers should have anti-HAV titres above the minimum protective threshold for 20 years or more following immunisation with two doses of this aluminium-free vaccine.
本研究的目的是预测用无铝灭活病毒体甲型肝炎疫苗免疫后诱导的长期保护作用。研究人群包括参加四项不同临床试验的成年志愿者。通过使用线性混合模型来估计血清抗体随时间的持久性,计算出较低的95%置信区间下限和血清转化率。为了评估数学模型的稳健性,进行了几次敏感性分析,采用了更保守的保护阈值(20 mIU/ml对10 mIU/ml)、更高的年下降率,并排除了随时间滴度增加的志愿者。基于190名从第3年起至少有两次有效滴度评估的志愿者,保护的中位持续时间为55.5年,95%置信区间下限为48.7年。预测只有5%的受试者保护持续时间低于25.3年。女性最初的滴度往往较高,但她们的下降率更高,总体上保护持续时间相似。使用更保守的阈值、更高的年下降率以及排除随时间滴度增加的志愿者并没有影响这些结果。根据该模型,95%的志愿者在接种两剂这种无铝疫苗后,其抗甲型肝炎病毒滴度应在最低保护阈值以上持续20年或更长时间。