Kinsella T D, Verhoef M J
Office of Medical Bioethics, Faculty of Medicine, University of Calgary, 3330 Hospital Dr. N.W., Calgary AB T2N 4N1, Canada.
Ann R Coll Physicians Surg Can. 1999 Jun;32(4):211-5.
To ascertain the opinions of practising Canadian physicians about their willingness to participate in legalized physician-assisted suicide; and to seek possible associations between willingness to practise legalized assisted suicide, and personal and medical professional determinants.
Cross-sectional, mailed survey of a random sample of Canadian physicians, stratified non-proportionally with respect to five geographic regions, and proportionally for type of practice (general practitioner or specialist).
Useable responses came from 2,010 (59 per cent) physicians (regional range 53 to 64 per cent), of whom 1,855 were in clinical practice. Respondents' gender and type of practice did not deviate from national reference data; 57 per cent were unwilling to practice legalized assisted suicide, but 40 per cent would wish it for themselves. Significantly different associations were found between opinions about willingness to practise legalized assisted suicide and the personal determinants of age, geographic regions, country of graduation, and religious activity, but not for gender, and type or experience in practice and terminal care.
The opinions of Canadian physicians about the practice of legalized physician-assisted suicide are more strongly influenced by personal determinants than by medical professional determinants. This reveals potential conflicts between physicians' professional and personal preferences. In this context, a plurality of Canadian physicians supports legislated change, but most would not practise legalized physician-assisted suicide at this time in Canada.
确定加拿大执业医生对于参与合法化的医生协助自杀的意愿;并探寻在实施合法化协助自杀的意愿与个人及医学专业因素之间可能存在的关联。
对加拿大医生的随机样本进行横断面邮寄调查,按五个地理区域进行非比例分层,按执业类型(全科医生或专科医生)进行比例分层。
收到2010名(59%)医生的有效回复(各区域回复率在53%至64%之间),其中1855人从事临床工作。受访者的性别和执业类型与全国参考数据无偏差;57%的人不愿意实施合法化的协助自杀,但40%的人希望自己能得到这种协助。在关于实施合法化协助自杀的意愿的观点与年龄、地理区域、毕业国家和宗教活动等个人因素之间发现了显著不同的关联,但在性别、执业类型或经验以及临终关怀方面未发现此类关联。
加拿大医生对于合法化的医生协助自杀的观点受个人因素的影响大于医学专业因素。这揭示了医生的专业偏好与个人偏好之间可能存在的冲突。在此背景下,多数加拿大医生支持立法变革,但目前在加拿大,大多数医生不会实施合法化的医生协助自杀。