Nilsson T, Olausson A, Johnsson H, Nyman U, Aspelin P
Department of Thoracic Radiology, Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Acta Radiol. 2002 Sep;43(5):486-91.
To retrospectively evaluate the clinical outcome of non-anticoagulated patients with clinically suspected acute pulmonary embolism (PE) and no symptoms or signs of deep venous thrombosis (DVT) following a negative contrast medium-enhanced spiral CT of the pulmonary arteries (s-CTPA).
During a 24-month period, 739 of 751 patients underwent s-CTPA with acceptable diagnostic quality for clinically suspected acute PE. All patients who had a CT study not positive for PE were followed up with a questionnaire, a telephone interview and review of all medical reports, including autopsies and death certificates for any episodes of venous thromboembolism (VTE) during a 3-month period.
PE was diagnosed in 158 patients. Of the remaining 581 patients with a negative s-CTPA, 45 patients were lost to follow-up. 88 patients were excluded because of anticoagulation treatment (cardiac disorder n=32, chronic VTE or acute symptomatic DVT n=31, PE diagnosed at pulmonary angiography n=1, thrombus prophylaxis during diagnostic work-up or other reasons than VTE n=24) and 7 patients undergoing lower extremity venous studies because of symptoms of DVT (all negative). Thus, 441 patients with a negative s-CTPA and no DVT symptoms, venous studies or anticoagulant treatment constituted the follow-up cohort. Four of these patients had proven VTE (all PE) during the 3-month follow-up period. Two of the PE episodes contributed to the patient's death.
Patients with clinically suspected acute PE, no symptoms or signs of DVT and a negative single slice s-CTPA using 3-5 mm collimation, may safely be left without anticoagulation treatment unless they are critically ill, have a limited cardiopulmonary reserve and/or if a high clinical suspicion remains.
回顾性评估临床疑似急性肺栓塞(PE)且无深静脉血栓形成(DVT)症状或体征的非抗凝患者在肺动脉造影剂增强螺旋CT(s-CTPA)检查结果为阴性后的临床结局。
在24个月期间,751例患者中的739例接受了s-CTPA检查,其诊断质量可接受,用于临床疑似急性PE的诊断。所有CT检查未发现PE阳性的患者均通过问卷调查、电话访谈以及查阅所有医疗报告进行随访,包括在3个月期间内任何静脉血栓栓塞(VTE)事件的尸检和死亡证明。
158例患者被诊断为PE。在其余581例s-CTPA检查结果为阴性的患者中,45例失访。88例患者因抗凝治疗被排除(心脏疾病n = 32,慢性VTE或急性症状性DVT n = 31,肺血管造影诊断为PE n = 1,诊断检查期间的血栓预防或非VTE的其他原因n = 24),7例因DVT症状接受下肢静脉检查的患者(均为阴性)。因此,441例s-CTPA检查结果为阴性且无DVT症状、静脉检查或抗凝治疗的患者构成了随访队列。在3个月的随访期内,这些患者中有4例被证实发生了VTE(均为PE)。其中2例PE发作导致患者死亡。
临床疑似急性PE、无DVT症状或体征且使用3 - 5mm准直的单层s-CTPA检查结果为阴性的患者,除非病情危重、心肺储备有限和/或临床高度怀疑,否则可以安全地不进行抗凝治疗。