Vahlensieck M, Okweschokwu S, Greven M
Radiologie Haydnhaus, Radiologisch-Nuklearmedizinische, Bonn, Germany. www.Radiologische-Gemeinschaftspraxis-Bonn.de.
Rofo. 2002 Nov;174(11):1415-21. doi: 10.1055/s-2002-35344.
To evaluate the influence of MRI of the temporomandibular joint on the therapeutic strategy in patients with craniomandibular disorders (internal derangement) and, furthermore, to analyze interobserver agreement for defined MRI criteria.
Fifty-one unilateral and bilateral MRI examinations of 32 patients were enrolled. Therapeutic strategies before and after performance of the MRI were compared. Retrospectively, two radiologists independently analyzed the MR images for position of the disk, position of the condyle, signal intensity of the disk and bilaminar zone, osseous changes and several additional findings, using a check list. Agreement was tested by kappa statistics.
In 56% of the cases, changes of the therapeutic regimen were registered after MRI. Statistically significant agreement of the two observers was found for anterior position of the disk (kappa = 0.44), transverse position of the disk (kappa = 0.46) and position of the condyle (kappa = 0.45). No significant agreement was found for signal intensity of the disk (kappa = 0.14) or bilaminar zone (kappa = 0.24), osseous changes (kappa = 0.13) and the additional findings (kappa = 0.29).
MRI has a measurable impact on the therapeutic approach to the internal derangement of the TMJ. The position of the disk and condyle can be reproducibly judged, while the signal intensity of the disk and bilaminar zone and the osseous changes are subject to wide observer variations.
评估颞下颌关节磁共振成像(MRI)对颅下颌关节紊乱病(关节内紊乱)患者治疗策略的影响,并分析观察者之间对特定MRI标准的一致性。
纳入32例患者的51次单侧和双侧MRI检查。比较MRI检查前后的治疗策略。回顾性地,两名放射科医生使用检查表独立分析MR图像,以观察盘的位置、髁突的位置、盘和双板区的信号强度、骨质改变及其他一些发现。通过kappa统计检验一致性。
56%的病例在MRI检查后记录到治疗方案的改变。两名观察者在盘的前位(kappa = 0.44)、盘的横向位置(kappa = 0.46)和髁突位置(kappa = 0.45)上有统计学意义的一致性。在盘(kappa = 0.14)或双板区(kappa = 0.24)的信号强度、骨质改变(kappa = 0.13)和其他发现(kappa = 0.29)方面未发现显著一致性。
MRI对颞下颌关节内紊乱的治疗方法有可测量的影响。盘和髁突的位置可以重复判断,而盘和双板区的信号强度以及骨质改变在观察者之间存在很大差异。