Harms Wolfgang, Krempien Robert, Hensley Frank W, Berns Christiane, Fritz Peter, Wannenmacher Michael
Department of Clinical Radiology, Radiation Therapy, University of Heidelberg, Germany.
Strahlenther Onkol. 2002 Nov;178(11):607-14. doi: 10.1007/s00066-002-0977-9.
The aim of this study was to evaluate effect, toxicity, and cosmesis of a prospectively applied pulsed dose rate (PDR) brachytherapy boost schedule in patients with stage I/II/IIIa invasive breast cancer.
A total of 113 patients were treated after breast-conserving surgery (BCS) and external beam radiotherapy (median 50 Gy, range 46-52). The boost dose was graded in accordance to the pathologic tumor characteristics: 20-25 Gy: incomplete resection (n = 34), vascular invasion (n = 27), close margin resection (n = 41); 15 Gy: T2G3 stage (n = 11). PDR brachytherapy (37 GBq, (192)Ir source) was carried out after geometric volume optimization with 1 Gy/pulse/h. The implantation and dose specification were performed similar to the rules of the Paris system.
The overall local failure rate after a median follow-up of 61 months was 4.4% (5/113). The actuarial 5- and 8-year local recurrence-free survival rates were 95% and 93%, respectively. Cosmesis was rated by 90% of the patients as excellent or good. 14/113 patients experienced grade III (all caused by planar telangiectasia) and none of the patients grade IV late toxicity of the skin (RTOG/EORTC). A boost dose of 25 Gy resulted in a significantly higher rate of late toxicity (Fisher's exact test, p < 0.01).
PDR brachytherapy is safe, effective, and provides good cosmesis. A CLDR breast boost can be replaced by PDR brachytherapy without significant loss of therapeutic ratio.
本研究旨在评估前瞻性应用的脉冲剂量率(PDR)近距离放疗加量方案对I/II/IIIa期浸润性乳腺癌患者的疗效、毒性和美容效果。
113例患者在保乳手术(BCS)和外照射放疗(中位剂量50 Gy,范围46 - 52 Gy)后接受治疗。根据病理肿瘤特征对加量剂量进行分级:20 - 25 Gy:切除不完全(n = 34)、血管侵犯(n = 27)、切缘接近(n = 41);15 Gy:T2G3期(n = 11)。在进行几何体积优化后,以1 Gy/脉冲/小时的剂量率进行PDR近距离放疗(37 GBq,铱-192源)。植入和剂量设定按照巴黎系统的规则进行。
中位随访61个月后的总体局部失败率为4.4%(5/113)。5年和8年的精算局部无复发生存率分别为95%和93%。90%的患者对美容效果的评价为优秀或良好。113例患者中有14例出现III级(均由扁平毛细血管扩张引起),无患者出现皮肤IV级晚期毒性(RTOG/EORTC标准)。25 Gy的加量剂量导致晚期毒性发生率显著更高(Fisher精确检验,p < 0.01)。
PDR近距离放疗安全、有效,且美容效果良好。PDR近距离放疗可替代腔内近距离放疗加量,而不会显著降低治疗比。