Chabeli M M
Nursing Science Department, RAU.
Curationis. 2002 Aug;25(3):10-8. doi: 10.4102/curationis.v25i3.773.
This article seeks to establish whether the poster presentation of a specific theme can facilitate the student's thinking skills in nursing education. A qualitative, exploratory, descriptive and contextual research design where twenty students volunteered to take part in the study by signing an informed consent was followed. Descriptive naïve sketches were used for data collection followed by individual interviews to validate the findings. Data was analysed by means of the descriptive method of open coding of Tesch (in Creswell, 1994:155). DENOSA's ethical standards for research (1998:7) were considered. The findings indicated both positive and negative perceptions. The positive perceptions were: a poster presentation as an evaluation method facilitates creative, critical and reflective thinking skills; group work facilitates student participation; it facilitates problem solving skills; it increases the student's independence and a sense of ownership; and the evaluation is fair. The negative perceptions were that there was a lack of clarity on the student's expectations and that group activity is difficult. Trustworthiness was maintained in accordance with Lincoln and Guba's principles (1985:290-327). It is concluded that a poster presentation, used effectively as an evaluation method, can facilitate the learner's critical and reflective thinking skills. It is recommended that other learner-centred methods of assessment and evaluation be researched for their effective use in facilitating the higher order thinking skills of learners.
本文旨在确定特定主题的海报展示是否能促进护理教育中学生的思维能力。采用了定性、探索性、描述性和情境性研究设计,20名学生通过签署知情同意书自愿参与该研究。使用描述性的原始草图收集数据,随后进行个人访谈以验证研究结果。数据采用特施(在克雷斯韦尔,1994:155)的开放式编码描述性方法进行分析。考虑了南非护士专业组织(DENOSA)的研究伦理标准(1998:7)。研究结果显示了积极和消极的看法。积极的看法是:海报展示作为一种评估方法有助于培养创造性、批判性和反思性思维能力;小组合作有助于学生参与;有助于培养解决问题的能力;增强学生的独立性和主人翁意识;并且评估是公平的。消极的看法是学生的期望不明确,小组活动困难。根据林肯和古巴的原则(1985:290 - 327)保持了研究的可信度。结论是,海报展示作为一种有效的评估方法,可以促进学习者的批判性和反思性思维能力。建议研究其他以学习者为中心的评估方法,以有效促进学习者的高阶思维能力。