Whittle Ian R
Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Edinburgh University, Western General Hospital, UK.
Curr Opin Neurol. 2002 Dec;15(6):663-9. doi: 10.1097/01.wco.0000044761.39452.38.
To assess selected papers on surgery for glioma for their impact on clinical practice.
Recent developments in surgical neuro-oncology for gliomas have centred around technological advances that enable the fusion of preoperative structural and functional imaging datasets, the use of intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging scanning, and awake craniotomy and cortical stimulation as means to maximize glioma resection, minimize postoperative morbidity, and improve survival times. Correlations of preoperative functional imaging information with operative awake neurophysiological findings are good, but the problem of brain shift during resective surgery remains problematical and is a cogent reason for using intraoperative magnetic resonance imaging. Two reviews showed little evidence to support the concept that 'aggressive' resection of both high and low-grade gliomas significantly prolongs the life of patients. Attempting radical excision of these tumours can have unfortunate consequences in eloquent brain regions, particularly as functional studies confirm brain activity within the limits of many gliomas.
Despite amazing technical advances in the investigation, assessment and surgical management of patients with glioma, the lack of an evidence basis for 'aggressive' resective management continues to pose dilemmas for surgeons.
评估关于胶质瘤手术的部分论文对临床实践的影响。
胶质瘤外科神经肿瘤学的最新进展集中在技术进步上,这些技术进步能够实现术前结构和功能成像数据集的融合、术中磁共振成像扫描的应用,以及清醒开颅和皮质刺激,以此来最大化胶质瘤切除、最小化术后发病率并延长生存时间。术前功能成像信息与术中清醒神经生理学发现之间的相关性良好,但切除性手术期间的脑移位问题仍然存在,这是使用术中磁共振成像的一个令人信服的理由。两项综述显示,几乎没有证据支持“积极”切除高级别和低级别胶质瘤能显著延长患者生命这一概念。试图根治性切除这些肿瘤在明确的脑区可能会产生不良后果,特别是功能研究证实许多胶质瘤范围内存在脑活动。
尽管在胶质瘤患者的研究、评估和手术管理方面取得了惊人的技术进步,但“积极”切除性治疗缺乏证据基础,这继续给外科医生带来困境。