Havas Magda
Environmental and Resource Studies, Trent University, Peterborough, Ontario, Canada.
Sci Total Environ. 2002 Oct 21;298(1-3):183-206. doi: 10.1016/s0048-9697(02)00198-5.
Electric and magnetic fields were measured during the summer of 1998 in south-central Ontario within the business district of 60 communities, ranging in size from 1000 to 2.3 million people. The mean magnetic flux density for the 60 communities was 5.8 mG. Communities with larger populations generally had higher magnetic flux densities than those with smaller populations. Communities with populations above 100,000, between 50,000 and 100,000, between 10,000 and 50,000, and less than 10,000 had mean magnetic flux densities of 14, 7, 4 and 2.4 mG, respectively. The city of Kingston, population 123,000, had the highest mean magnetic flux density (47 mG) while Burks Falls, population 1000, had the lowest (0.8 mG). More than 90% of the sites measured in Kingston, Toronto, Oshawa, London, Pickering Village and Bellville were above 2 mG, the lower limit associated with childhood cancers. In only one community (Burks Falls) were all of the measurements in the business district below 2 mG. Diurnal variations were detected in the magnetic field (but not in the electric field) with highest fields measured during business hours. For electric fields, the mean for the 60 communities was 3.2 V/m. Electric fields were generally low. Eight communities had maximum field strengths above 30 V/m and all of these were associated with overhead wires. In larger communities with underground distribution lines the electric fields were low or undetectable (<0.1 V/m) but the magnetic fields were often high. High electric fields were generally associated with low magnetic fields but the relationship was not sufficiently robust to enable prediction of one from the other. Data for the business district measured during business hours appear to be relatively consistent for both electric field and magnetic flux density over a two-year period. Two classification schemes that can be used independently or in combination are proposed to facilitate community comparisons. One is based on the average intensity of the fields (FI) and the other on the percentage of measurements that exceed a critical limit (CL) that has biological significance. The critical value of 5 V/m is proposed for electric fields and 2 mG for magnetic fields. Both classification schemes use the traffic light analogy for exposure (green-low, amber-medium, red-high exposure) with an additional category (black) for very high exposure. This classification system facilitates information transfer and can easily be understood and used by the public, public utilities, policy makers, and those wanting to practice prudent avoidance.
1998年夏季,在安大略省中南部60个社区的商业区测量了电场和磁场,这些社区人口规模从1000人到230万人不等。60个社区的平均磁通密度为5.8毫高斯。人口较多的社区通常比人口较少的社区具有更高的磁通密度。人口超过10万、5万至10万、1万至5万以及少于1万的社区,其平均磁通密度分别为14、7、4和2.4毫高斯。金斯顿市人口12.3万,平均磁通密度最高(47毫高斯),而伯克斯福尔斯镇人口1000,平均磁通密度最低(0.8毫高斯)。在金斯顿、多伦多、奥沙瓦、伦敦、皮克林村和贝尔维尔测量的地点中,超过90%高于2毫高斯,这是与儿童癌症相关的下限。只有一个社区(伯克斯福尔斯)商业区的所有测量值都低于2毫高斯。在磁场中检测到了日变化(但电场中未检测到),在营业时间测量到的磁场最高。对于电场,60个社区的平均值为3.2伏/米。电场一般较低。有八个社区的最大场强高于30伏/米,所有这些都与架空电线有关。在有地下配电线路的较大社区中,电场较低或无法检测到(<0.1伏/米),但磁场往往较高。高电场通常与低磁场相关,但这种关系不够稳固,无法根据一个预测另一个。在两年期间,营业时间内在商业区测量的电场和磁通密度数据似乎相对一致。提出了两种可单独使用或组合使用的分类方案,以方便社区之间的比较。一种基于场的平均强度(FI),另一种基于超过具有生物学意义的临界限值(CL)的测量百分比。对于电场,建议临界值为5伏/米;对于磁场,建议为2毫高斯。两种分类方案都使用交通信号灯类比来表示暴露情况(绿色 - 低暴露,琥珀色 - 中等暴露,红色 - 高暴露),还有一个额外的类别(黑色)表示极高暴露。这种分类系统便于信息传递,并且公众、公用事业公司、政策制定者以及希望谨慎避免的人都能轻松理解和使用。