Michelotti Janine, Charman Tony, Slonims Vicky, Baird Gillian
Donald Winnicott Centre, City and Hackney Community Services, NHS Trust, London, UK.
Dev Med Child Neurol. 2002 Dec;44(12):812-9. doi: 10.1017/s0012162201002985.
Eighteen children (13 males, five females) who had severe developmental language delay/disorder and some features of autism (although insufficient in severity and combination to meet ICD-10 diagnostic criteria for childhood autism) at preschool age (Time 1; mean age 4 years 4 months) were followed up 4 years later (Time 2; mean age 8 years 7 months). At the initial assessment the diagnostic dilemma was how much the social communication impairments and behavioural problems were secondary to the language problem and how much they constituted a genuine case of a pervasive developmental disorder. It was anticipated that at follow-up some children would continue to show social impairments but that in others social impairments would have receded as language competence improved. Follow-up assessments included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, the Children's Communication Checklist, and the Social Communication Questionnaire. At follow-up, five children had continuing language disorder and were considered to fulfil diagnostic criteria for childhood autism, four children had continuing language disorder and met criteria for atypical autism, and nine met criteria for atypical autism but had somewhat recovered language skills. Thus, even in the subgroup of children whose language ability had improved the features of autism had not dissipated. Severity of social communication impairments and repetitive behaviours at Time 1, rated retrospectively from case notes, were associated with severity of autism symptoms and pragmatic competence at Time 2. The findings are discussed in relation to the unclear boundary between autism spectrum disorders and language delay/disorder.
18名儿童(13名男性,5名女性)在学龄前阶段(时间1;平均年龄4岁4个月)患有严重的发育性语言延迟/障碍以及一些自闭症特征(尽管严重程度和特征组合不足以满足ICD - 10儿童自闭症诊断标准),4年后(时间2;平均年龄8岁7个月)对他们进行了随访。在初始评估时,诊断困境在于社交沟通障碍和行为问题在多大程度上继发于语言问题,以及在多大程度上构成了真正的广泛性发育障碍病例。预计在随访时,一些儿童将继续表现出社交障碍,但另一些儿童的社交障碍会随着语言能力的提高而减轻。随访评估包括韦氏儿童智力量表、语言基本能力临床评估、儿童沟通检查表和社交沟通问卷。随访时,5名儿童持续存在语言障碍,被认为符合儿童自闭症诊断标准,4名儿童持续存在语言障碍,符合非典型自闭症标准,9名儿童符合非典型自闭症标准但语言技能有所恢复。因此,即使在语言能力有所提高的儿童亚组中,自闭症特征也没有消失。根据病例记录回顾性评定的时间1时社交沟通障碍和重复行为的严重程度,与时间2时自闭症症状的严重程度和语用能力相关。结合自闭症谱系障碍与语言延迟/障碍之间不明确的界限对研究结果进行了讨论。