Playfer J R
Royal Liverpool University Hospital, Prescot Street, UK.
Eur J Neurol. 2002 Nov;9 Suppl 3:55-8. doi: 10.1046/j.1468-1331.9.s3.7.x.
The information explosion in Parkinson's disease challenges the individual clinician to apply available knowledge to the management of individual patients. The application of current algorithms and guidelines is not straightforward in the older patient. Decision analysis reveals that clinical decisions may be simple, complex or chaotic. The more factors that have to be taken into account in making a decision, the more that decision moves from being evidence-based to intuitive. Decisions are made within conceptual frameworks. The dominant models in Parkinson's disease are biomedical or rehabilitation-based. Although the rehabilitation model lacks a sound evidence base, it is the principles of rehabilitation that dominate the management of the older patient. Analysis of the decisions made in a Parkinson's disease clinic demonstrates that the doctor's role is complex and many decisions taken are not evidence-based. Parkinson's disease is not a simple movement disorder but a neuro-psychiatric complex. The incurable nature and chronicity of the disease dictate the need for multidisciplinary working. Quality of life studies reveal wide variations in the expectations and needs of patients. Studies of the impact and costs of the disease put the cost of drugs into perspective. Studies in Parkinson's disease can involve very different populations. A cohort of elderly patients shows significant differences from the populations who are selected to participate in multi-centre trials. There is an increasing challenge for geriatricians to ensure that pragmatic trials are undertaken. Psychiatric problems - dementia, depression, and hallucinations - are common in the elderly and best management of these problems is unclear. Choices in drug regimes need to take into account the complex interactions between ageing, comorbility and Parkinson's disease.
帕金森病领域的信息爆炸对临床医生个人提出了挑战,要求他们将现有知识应用于个体患者的管理。在老年患者中应用当前的算法和指南并非易事。决策分析表明,临床决策可能简单、复杂或混乱。做出决策时需要考虑的因素越多,该决策就越从基于证据转向凭直觉。决策是在概念框架内做出的。帕金森病领域占主导地位的模式是生物医学模式或基于康复的模式。尽管康复模式缺乏可靠的证据基础,但正是康复原则主导着老年患者的管理。对帕金森病诊所所做决策的分析表明,医生的角色很复杂,许多决策并非基于证据。帕金森病并非简单的运动障碍,而是一种神经精神综合征。该疾病的不可治愈性和慢性决定了需要多学科协作。生活质量研究揭示了患者期望和需求的巨大差异。对该疾病影响和成本的研究使药物成本得到了合理看待。帕金森病研究可能涉及非常不同的人群。一组老年患者与被选入多中心试验的人群存在显著差异。老年医学专家面临着越来越大的挑战,要确保开展务实的试验。精神问题——痴呆、抑郁和幻觉——在老年人中很常见,而这些问题的最佳管理方法尚不清楚。药物治疗方案的选择需要考虑衰老、共病和帕金森病之间的复杂相互作用。