Qidwai W, Azam S I, Ali S S, Ayub S
Aga Khan University Hospital, Dow Medical College, Karachi.
J Pak Med Assoc. 2002 Jun;52(6):269-72.
To study the utilization of services of Health care providers among patients presenting to Family Physicians in a teaching hospital in Karachi.
It was a cross sectional study. A questionnaire was developed to collect patient's utilization of services of health care providers. The investigators administered the questionnaire to 387 patients, after purpose of the study was explained, written consent was taken and confidentiality was assured.
The study population included more females than males, with average age of 32.6 years. The majority were married, well educated, in private and government service, were students or housewives. We found that 383(99%), 141(36.4%), 88(22.7%) and 45(11.6%) of the respondents had used services of allopaths, homeopaths, hakims and spiritual healers respectively. It is important to consider that these patients had come for allopathic treatment, thus exhibiting preference for it. The five main ailments for consulting health care providers differed, suggesting the perception in the mind of patients that certain ailments are better treated by particular system of treatment than the others. Studies are needed to explore this area further. The main reasons for consultation with particular health care provider were the recommendation of others or the perceived effectiveness of the practitioners. The reasons cited for non-consultation with health care providers were the lack of belief in them or lack of effectiveness of their treatment. Three hundred seventy nine (98%), 259 (67%), 174 (45%) and 249 (64.4%) of patients were willing to consult allopaths, homeopaths, hakims and spiritual healers again respectively, if unwell in future.
We found a substantial utilization of services of complimentary medicine practitioners among patients seeking allopathic treatment. Further study on the utilization and organization of services offered by health care providers is required.
研究卡拉奇一家教学医院中向家庭医生求诊的患者对医疗服务提供者服务的利用情况。
这是一项横断面研究。设计了一份问卷以收集患者对医疗服务提供者服务的利用情况。在解释研究目的后,研究人员向387名患者发放了问卷,获取了书面同意并确保了保密性。
研究人群中女性多于男性,平均年龄为32.6岁。大多数人已婚,受过良好教育,从事私营和政府工作,是学生或家庭主妇。我们发现,分别有383名(99%)、141名(36.4%)、88名(22.7%)和45名(11.6%)的受访者使用过西医、顺势疗法医生、哈基姆医生和精神治疗师的服务。需要考虑的是,这些患者前来接受西医治疗,因此表现出对其的偏好。咨询医疗服务提供者的五大主要疾病各不相同,这表明患者认为某些疾病用特定治疗体系治疗比其他体系更好。需要进一步研究以深入探讨这一领域。咨询特定医疗服务提供者的主要原因是他人的推荐或对从业者治疗效果的认知。未咨询医疗服务提供者的原因是对其缺乏信任或认为其治疗无效。如果未来身体不适,分别有379名(98%)、259名(67%)、174名(45%)和249名(64.4%)患者愿意再次咨询西医、顺势疗法医生、哈基姆医生和精神治疗师。
我们发现,在寻求西医治疗的患者中,对补充医学从业者服务的利用程度较高。需要对医疗服务提供者提供的服务的利用和组织进行进一步研究。