Doğan H Serkan, Sahin Ahmet, Cetinkaya Yeşim, Akdoğan Bülent, Ozden Ender, Kendi Sezer
Department of Urology, Section of Infectious Diseases, Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
J Endourol. 2002 Nov;16(9):649-53. doi: 10.1089/089277902761402989.
To compare single-dose and short-course antibiotic prophylaxis protocols in percutaneous nephrolithotomy.
Eighty-one patients with sterile urine preoperatively who underwent percutaneous nephrolithotomy were divided into two groups. The first group (N = 43) received a single intravenous dose of antibiotic (200 mg of ofloxacin) during anesthetic induction, and the second group (N = 38) received treatment doses of antibiotic (400 mg of ofloxacin per day) until the nephrostomy catheter was removed. The two groups were identical according to demographic and treatment characteristics. For each patient, microbiologic evaluation of extracted stones and urine samples was done. If patients developed fever in the postoperative period, blood and urine cultures were taken. Factors that might have affected the development of postoperative fever and infection were analyzed.
Nine patients in the first group had postoperative fever. Three had bacteriuria, and one had bacteremia. In the second group, eight patients had fever. One had bacteriuria and bacteremia. Nineteen patients (eleven in the first group, eight in the second) had positive stone cultures. No statistical difference was observed between the two groups in terms of bacteriuria, bacteremia, positive stone cultures, or postoperative fever. The febrile patients had longer operations with the use of more irrigation fluid and longer postoperative hospital stays.
In patients whose preoperative urine cultures are sterile, short-term prophylaxis has no advantage over single-dose prophylaxis as a means of preventing infection. The duration of surgery and the amount of irrigation fluid are significant risk factors for postoperative fever.
比较经皮肾镜取石术中单剂量和短疗程抗生素预防方案。
81例术前尿液无菌且接受经皮肾镜取石术的患者被分为两组。第一组(n = 43)在麻醉诱导期间接受单次静脉注射抗生素(200mg氧氟沙星),第二组(n = 38)接受抗生素治疗剂量(每天400mg氧氟沙星)直至肾造瘘导管拔除。两组在人口统计学和治疗特征方面相同。对每位患者的取出结石和尿液样本进行微生物学评估。如果患者术后出现发热,则进行血培养和尿培养。分析可能影响术后发热和感染发生的因素。
第一组9例患者术后发热。3例有菌尿,1例有菌血症。第二组8例患者发热。1例有菌尿和菌血症。19例患者(第一组11例,第二组8例)结石培养阳性。两组在菌尿、菌血症、结石培养阳性或术后发热方面未观察到统计学差异。发热患者手术时间更长,使用的冲洗液更多,术后住院时间更长。
对于术前尿培养无菌的患者,作为预防感染的手段,短期预防并不比单剂量预防更具优势。手术时间和冲洗液量是术后发热的重要危险因素。