Pokorny A D, Kaplan H B
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1976 Feb;162(2):119-25. doi: 10.1097/00005053-197602000-00006.
The hypothesis was tested that following psychiatric hospitalization, those subjects who subsequently completed suicide would be distinguished from those who did not by the interaction of two circumstances: a state of defenselessness at the time of hospitalization, and experience of adverse life events following release from hospital. Subjects were 40 male VA psychiatric inpatients: 20 who completed suicide following release, and 20 controls matched on age, race, and time at risk in the community. Defenselessness (the incapacity to defend against distressful negative self-feelings) was defined in terms of scores derived from the extended Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale administered shortly after the patient's hospitalization. Adverse life events were eight events characterized simultaneously as undesirable, unlikely to have been initiated by the subject, and having a score of 30 or above on the Social Readjustment Rating Scale. In confirmation of the hypothesis, it was found that completed suicide subjects were significantly and appreciably more likely both to have had high defenselessness scores at the time of hospitalization and to have experienced adverse life events during the posthospitalization period, whereas neither circumstance in the absence of the other was predictive. The findings support the position that suicide is a response to experiences with self-threatening implications, in the face of personal incapacity to defend against, adapt to, or cope with such experiences.
在精神科住院治疗后,那些随后自杀的患者与未自杀的患者可通过两种情况的相互作用加以区分:住院时的无助状态,以及出院后经历的不良生活事件。研究对象为40名男性退伍军人事务部精神科住院患者:20名在出院后自杀,20名作为对照,在年龄、种族和社区风险时长方面与之匹配。无助感(即无法抵御痛苦的负面自我感受)是根据患者住院后不久进行的扩展版简明精神病评定量表得出的分数来定义的。不良生活事件是指同时具备以下特征的八类事件:不受欢迎、不太可能由个体引发,且在社会再适应评定量表上得分达到30分及以上。为验证该假设,研究发现,自杀身亡的患者在住院时更有可能出现高分的无助感,且在出院后更有可能经历不良生活事件,而单独来看,这两种情况均无预测作用。这些发现支持了这样一种观点,即自杀是面对个人无法抵御、适应或应对具有自我威胁性影响的经历时的一种反应。