Cunningham Peter J, Hadley Jack, Reschovsky James
Center for Studying Health System Change, USA.
Med Care Res Rev. 2002 Dec;59(4):359-83. doi: 10.1177/107755802237807.
The State Children's Health Insurance Program (SCHIP) was designed to increase the number of children with health insurance coverage without resulting in large numbers of children substituting public coverage for private insurance. This study uses data from the Community Tracking Study collected before and after SCHIP implementation to examine the effects of increases in eligibility for public coverage on children's health insurance coverage. Using a regression-based difference-in-differences approach, the authors find that increases in eligibility for public coverage did increase the likelihood of having Medicaid or other state coverage versus being uninsured for the primary SCHIP target population--children in families with incomes between 100 and 200 percent of the federal poverty level. However, eligibility increases also increased the likelihood of having public coverage versus private insurance for this income group, indicating that SCHIP expansions resulted in substitution of public for private insurance. In fact, simulation results indicate that the initial impact of SCHIP on private insurance coverage has been far greater than on uninsurance rates. These results reflect the early stages of SCHIP implementation, however, and are subject to change as the SCHIP programs mature.
国家儿童健康保险计划(SCHIP)旨在增加有医疗保险覆盖的儿童数量,同时不会导致大量儿童用公共保险替代私人保险。本研究使用在SCHIP实施前后收集的社区追踪研究数据,来检验公共保险资格增加对儿童医疗保险覆盖的影响。作者采用基于回归的双重差分法发现,对于主要的SCHIP目标人群——收入在联邦贫困线100%至200%之间家庭的儿童,公共保险资格的增加确实提高了拥有医疗补助或其他州保险覆盖而非无保险的可能性。然而,资格增加也提高了该收入群体拥有公共保险而非私人保险的可能性,这表明SCHIP的扩张导致了用公共保险替代私人保险。事实上,模拟结果表明,SCHIP对私人保险覆盖的初始影响远大于对未保险率的影响。不过,这些结果反映的是SCHIP实施的早期阶段,并且会随着SCHIP项目的成熟而发生变化。