Twomey A, Esgate A
University of Westminster, London, UK.
Percept Mot Skills. 2002 Dec;95(3 Pt 1):1013-26. doi: 10.2466/pms.2002.95.3.1013.
The "Mozart effect" is the tendency to score higher on spatiotemporal IQ subscales following exposure to complex music such as Mozart's Sonata K.448. This phenomenon was investigated in 20 musicians and 20 nonmusicians. The trion model predicts increased synchrony between musical and spatiotemporal centres in the right cerebral hemisphere. Since increased left-hemispheric involvement in music processing occurs as a result of music training, predictions deriving from the possibility of increased synchrony with left-hemispheric areas in musicians were tested. These included improved performance on language as well as spatiotemporal tasks. Spatiotemporal, synonym generation, and rhyming word generation tasks were employed as was the Mozart Sonata K.448. A Mozart effect was demonstrated on the spatiotemporal task, and the facilitatory effect of exposure to Mozart was greater for the nonmusician group. This finding adds to the robustness of the Mozart effect since novel tasks were used. No Mozart effect was found for either group on the verbal tasks, although the musicians scored higher on rhyming word generation. This new finding adds to the number of nonmusical tasks apparently showing long-term benefits from music training. However, no systematic link was found between performance on any task and number of years spent in music training. The failure to induce a Mozart effect in the musician group on verbal tasks, as well as that group's limited facilitation on spatiotemporal tasks, may be associated with either a ceiling effect due to the long-term effects of music training or from methodological factors. Both possibilities are discussed.
“莫扎特效应”是指在接触诸如莫扎特《第448号奏鸣曲》等复杂音乐后,在时空智商子量表上得分更高的倾向。该现象在20名音乐家和20名非音乐家中进行了研究。三神经元模型预测右半球音乐与时空中枢之间的同步性会增强。由于音乐训练会导致左半球在音乐处理中的参与度增加,因此对音乐家与左半球区域同步性增加的可能性所产生的预测进行了测试。这些预测包括在语言以及时空任务上表现的改善。采用了时空、同义词生成和押韵词生成任务,同时也使用了莫扎特《第448号奏鸣曲》。在时空任务上证明了莫扎特效应,并且对于非音乐家组来说,接触莫扎特的促进作用更大。由于使用了新任务,这一发现增强了莫扎特效应的可信度。在语言任务上,两组均未发现莫扎特效应,尽管音乐家在押韵词生成方面得分更高。这一新发现增加了明显从音乐训练中获得长期益处的非音乐任务的数量。然而,在任何任务的表现与音乐训练年限之间未发现系统的关联。在音乐家组的语言任务上未能诱导出莫扎特效应,以及该组在时空任务上的促进作用有限,可能与音乐训练的长期影响导致的天花板效应或方法学因素有关。对这两种可能性都进行了讨论。