Jack C R, Slomkowski M, Gracon S, Hoover T M, Felmlee J P, Stewart K, Xu Y, Shiung M, O'Brien P C, Cha R, Knopman D, Petersen R C
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Mayo Clinic and Foundation, Rochester, MN, USA.
Neurology. 2003 Jan 28;60(2):253-60. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000042480.86872.03.
To assess the feasibility of using MRI measurements as a surrogate endpoint for disease progression in a therapeutic trial for AD.
A total of 362 patients with probable AD from 38 different centers participated in the MRI portion of a 52-week randomized placebo-controlled trial of milameline, a muscarinic receptor agonist. The therapeutic trial itself was not completed due to projected lack of efficacy on interim analysis; however, the MRI arm of the study was continued. Of the 362 subjects who underwent a baseline MRI study, 192 subjects underwent a second MRI 1 year later. Hippocampal volume and temporal horn volume were measured from the MRI scans.
The annualized percent changes in hippocampal volume (-4.9%) and temporal horn volume (16.1%) in the study patients were consistent with data from prior single-site studies. Correlations between the rate of MRI volumetric change and change in behavioral/cognitive measures were greater for the temporal horn than for the hippocampus. Decline over time was more consistently seen with imaging measures, 99% of the time for the hippocampus, than behavioral/cognitive measures (p < 0.001). Greater consistency in MRI than behavioral/clinical measures resulted in markedly lower estimated sample size requirements for clinical trials. The estimated number of subjects per arm required to detect a 50% reduction in the rate of decline over 1 year are: AD Assessment Scale-cognitive subscale 320; Mini-Mental Status Examination 241; hippocampal volume 21; temporal horn volume 54.
The consistency of MRI measurements obtained across sites, and the consistency between the multisite milameline data and that obtained in prior single-site studies, demonstrate the technical feasibility of using structural MRI measures as a surrogate endpoint of disease progression in therapeutic trials. However, validation of imaging as a biomarker of therapeutic efficacy in AD awaits a positive trial.
评估在一项针对阿尔茨海默病(AD)的治疗试验中,使用磁共振成像(MRI)测量作为疾病进展替代终点的可行性。
来自38个不同中心的总共362例可能患有AD的患者参与了一项为期52周的米拉醋铵(一种毒蕈碱受体激动剂)随机安慰剂对照试验的MRI部分。由于中期分析预计缺乏疗效,该治疗试验本身未完成;然而,该研究的MRI部分继续进行。在接受基线MRI检查的362名受试者中,192名受试者在1年后接受了第二次MRI检查。从MRI扫描中测量海马体积和颞角体积。
研究患者中海马体积(-4.9%)和颞角体积(16.1%)的年化百分比变化与先前单中心研究的数据一致。颞角的MRI体积变化率与行为/认知测量变化之间的相关性大于海马。随着时间的推移,成像测量比行为/认知测量更一致地观察到下降,海马为99%的时间(p<0.001)。MRI比行为/临床测量具有更高的一致性,导致临床试验所需的估计样本量显著降低。在1年内检测下降率降低50%所需的每组受试者估计数量为:AD评定量表-认知子量表320例;简易精神状态检查表241例;海马体积21例;颞角体积54例。
各站点获得的MRI测量的一致性,以及多中心米拉醋铵数据与先前单中心研究获得的数据之间的一致性,证明了在治疗试验中使用结构MRI测量作为疾病进展替代终点的技术可行性。然而,成像作为AD治疗疗效生物标志物的验证有待于一项阳性试验。