Lenert Leslie A
Section on Health Services Research, VA San Diego Healthcare System, California, USA.
Med Care. 2003 Feb;41(2):299-308. doi: 10.1097/01.MLR.0000044909.63278.0D.
There is a wide range of therapeutic options for migraine headaches, yet little is known about how patients value different treatment alternatives nor how to tailor treatments to patients' preferences.
Assess patients' preferences for outcomes of treatment of migraine headache based on their marginal willingness to pay (WTP) for treatment attributes.
In an Internet-based study, we used computer software to measure participants' WTP for a hypothetical ideal drug (one that was 100% effective, worked quickly, and had no adverse effects) and for other hypothetical drugs, each with one "less than ideal" attribute of performance.
Two hundred fifty-seven self-identified migraineurs recruited via an Internet Web site.
A high proportion of participants in the study had symptoms consistent with migraine etiology of headache (99%). Median "out-of-pocket" monthly WTP cost for an ideal migraine therapy was 130 dollars. WTP was associated with participants' own migraine experience: severity of pain, frequency of headaches, and the types of medications used in the past. WTP was reduced when pharmaceuticals offered less benefit, ranging from a mean of 74% of ideal for treatments that failed to relieve nausea, to 43% of ideal in treatments associated with a 50% chance of a rebound headache.
There is wide variability in patients' strength of preference for different attributes of migraine therapy. Choice of therapy for migraine headache should be individualized based on patients' preferences. WTP measures appear to be a valid and feasible metric for quantifying treatment preferences for migraine therapies.
偏头痛的治疗方法多种多样,但对于患者如何评估不同治疗方案的价值以及如何根据患者偏好定制治疗方案,我们知之甚少。
根据偏头痛治疗属性的边际支付意愿(WTP)评估患者对偏头痛治疗结果的偏好。
在一项基于互联网的研究中,我们使用计算机软件测量参与者对一种假设的理想药物(一种100%有效、起效快且无副作用的药物)以及其他假设药物的WTP,每种假设药物都有一个“不太理想”的性能属性。
通过互联网网站招募的257名自称偏头痛患者。
研究中很大一部分参与者的症状与偏头痛性头痛的病因相符(99%)。理想偏头痛治疗方案每月的“自付”WTP成本中位数为130美元。WTP与参与者自身的偏头痛经历相关:疼痛严重程度、头痛频率以及过去使用的药物类型。当药物疗效降低时,WTP也会降低,从未能缓解恶心的治疗方案的平均理想值的74%,到有50%机会出现反弹性头痛的治疗方案的平均理想值的43%。
患者对偏头痛治疗不同属性的偏好强度差异很大。偏头痛的治疗选择应根据患者的偏好进行个体化。WTP测量似乎是量化偏头痛治疗方案偏好的一种有效且可行的指标。