Raptopoulos Vassilios, Katsou Georgia, Rosen Max P, Siewert Bettina, Goldberg S Nahum, Kruskal Jonathan B
Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center and Harvard Medical School, 330 Brookline Ave, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
Radiology. 2003 Feb;226(2):521-6. doi: 10.1148/radiol.2262012097.
To explore the possibility of a relationship between increased use of computed tomography (CT) for diagnosis of appendicitis and increased occurrence of minimal or subtle CT and surgical findings.
Two groups, each with 50 consecutive patients who underwent CT before appendectomy in 1997 and 2000, were compared. CT scans and surgery-pathology reports were evaluated on a six-grade scale from normal to abscess or inflammatory mass. The demographics, surgical techniques, hospital stay, and grade distribution for the two groups were compared, and the CT results were correlated with surgical findings.
In 1997, CT was performed in 33% (50 of 152) of patients undergoing appendectomy, as compared with 59% (50 of 85) 3 years later (P <.001). There was excellent correlation between surgical-pathologic and CT grades (weighted kappa, 0.75; P <.001; Spearman rank correlation, 0.83). There was no significant difference in demographics, rate of surgery, or surgical techniques used, but there was a significant decrease in the median surgical-pathologic grades, from 3.0 to 2.5 (P =.05) for all patients and from 3.5 to 2.6 (P =.003) for patients who underwent CT. Similarly, the median CT grade decreased from 4 to 3 (P <.001). Seven patients had subtle CT findings in 1997 compared with 16 in 2000 (P =.004), and there was a significant decrease in mean hospital stay, from 2.8 days +/- 4 (SD) to 1.5 days +/- 2 (P =.008).
With increased CT use, there were less severe imaging findings, including absence of periappendiceal stranding, and a significant decrease in surgical-pathologic severity of appendiceal disease and hospital stay.
探讨增加使用计算机断层扫描(CT)诊断阑尾炎与CT及手术所见中轻微或细微表现增加之间存在关联的可能性。
比较两组患者,每组各有50例在1997年和2000年接受阑尾切除术前接受CT检查的连续患者。CT扫描和手术病理报告按从正常到脓肿或炎性肿块的六级标准进行评估。比较两组患者的人口统计学资料、手术技术、住院时间和分级分布,并将CT结果与手术所见进行关联分析。
1997年,接受阑尾切除术的患者中有33%(152例中的50例)进行了CT检查,而3年后这一比例为59%(85例中的50例)(P<.001)。手术病理分级与CT分级之间存在极好的相关性(加权kappa值为0.75;P<.001;Spearman等级相关性为0.83)。在人口统计学资料、手术率或所采用的手术技术方面没有显著差异,但所有患者的手术病理分级中位数从3.0降至2.5(P =.05),接受CT检查的患者从3.5降至2.6(P =.003)。同样,CT分级中位数从4降至3(P<.001)。1997年有7例患者有细微的CT表现,而2000年有16例(P =.004),平均住院时间显著缩短,从2.8天±4(标准差)降至1.5天±2(P =.008)。
随着CT使用的增加,包括阑尾周围无条索状影在内的影像学表现不那么严重,阑尾疾病的手术病理严重程度和住院时间显著降低。