Nelson J S, Carpenter R E, Durboraw D
Cancer Res. 1976 Feb;36(2 Pt 1):524-31.
C3HBA mammary tumors were irradiated with 3000 rads of 250-kVp X-rays or 1000 rads of 8-MeV neutrons, doses of radiation matched for producing equal growth delay. At 14 days postirradiation, tumors were regrowing at a reduced rate relative to controls. Cell kinetic parameters were examined using percentage of labeled mitoses techniques, and blood vessel spacing and tumor architecture were examined histologically to determine whether the mechanisms underlying growth rate changes were the same after neutron as after photon irradiation. The tumor volume-doubling time at 14 days posttreatment is similar in both irradiated groups (TD=117 hr for neutron-irradiated tumors, 132 hr for X-irradiated tumors) and is approximately twice as long as the doubling time of 61.4 hr in control tumors in the same size range. Control and X-irradiated tumors have median cell cycle durations of 19.3 and 18.5 hr, respectively; the more slowly growing X-irradiated tumors have a reduced growth fraction and increased cell loss factor. Regrowing neutron-irradiated tumors have a median cell cycle of 27.2 hr, with calculated growth fraction and cell loss factor values intermediate between those for control and X-irradiated tumors. Scatter in the percentage of labeled mitoses data makes it difficult to determine whether the cell cycle durations are significantly different. The average distance from tumor parenchymal interphase cells to the nearest recognizable blood vessel is nearly identical in the two irradiated groups and for both groups is significantly greater than interphase to vessel distance in controls. The average distance in irradiated tumors approaches the maximal distance for O2 diffusion in mouse adenocarcinomas of a corded structure surrounding a central blood vessel. Both neutron- and X-irradiated tumors contain more necrosis and fewer viable-appearing parenchymal cells than do control tumors of the same size. The similar growth rate and growth delay in this tumor after 3000 rads of X-rays of 1000 rads of neutrons occur in the face of possibly different cell cycle durations and seem related to similar circulatory system inadequacies which limit growth and are expressed as greater average cell-to-blood-vessel distance and increased cell loss leading to necrosis, indicating oxygen or nutrient deprivation.
用250千伏峰值的X射线3000拉德或8兆电子伏中子1000拉德对C3HBA乳腺肿瘤进行照射,这两种辐射剂量经匹配以产生相等的生长延迟。照射后14天,肿瘤相对于对照组以较低的速率再生长。使用标记有丝分裂百分比技术检查细胞动力学参数,并通过组织学检查血管间距和肿瘤结构,以确定中子照射后与光子照射后生长速率变化的潜在机制是否相同。两个照射组在治疗后14天的肿瘤体积倍增时间相似(中子照射的肿瘤TD = 117小时,X射线照射的肿瘤TD = 132小时),并且大约是相同大小范围内对照肿瘤61.4小时倍增时间的两倍。对照肿瘤和X射线照射的肿瘤的细胞周期中位数持续时间分别为19.3小时和18.5小时;生长较慢的X射线照射的肿瘤生长分数降低,细胞丢失因子增加。再生长的中子照射的肿瘤的细胞周期中位数为27.2小时,计算出的生长分数和细胞丢失因子值介于对照肿瘤和X射线照射的肿瘤之间。标记有丝分裂数据的离散性使得难以确定细胞周期持续时间是否有显著差异。两个照射组中肿瘤实质间期细胞到最近可识别血管的平均距离几乎相同,并且两组该距离均显著大于对照组中间期细胞到血管的距离。照射肿瘤中的平均距离接近小鼠腺癌中氧气扩散的最大距离,腺癌具有围绕中央血管的条索状结构。与相同大小的对照肿瘤相比,中子和X射线照射的肿瘤均含有更多坏死组织和更少外观存活的实质细胞。在可能不同的细胞周期持续时间情况下,3000拉德X射线或1000拉德中子照射后该肿瘤出现相似的生长速率和生长延迟,这似乎与相似的循环系统不足有关,循环系统不足限制生长,并表现为平均细胞到血管距离增加以及导致坏死的细胞丢失增加,提示氧气或营养物质缺乏。