Landau Mark E, Diaz Myrna I, Barner Kristen C, Campbell William W
Department of Neurology, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, 6900 Georgia Ave., Washington, DC 20307, USA.
Muscle Nerve. 2003 Mar;27(3):367-9. doi: 10.1002/mus.10297.
In 1972, Maynard and Stolov showed that the experimental error in calculating nerve conduction velocity (NCV) depends on errors of latency and distance measurements. Their data suggested that a minimum distance of 10 cm should be used when calculating NCV because of an increase in error >/= 25% at shorter distances. The object of this study was to reestablish the minimum distance using current technology. Twenty physicians measured the proximal and distal onset latencies of the same stored ulnar compound muscle action potentials, as well as the forearm skin distance. The mean and standard deviation of the errors in conduction time and distance were determined. A spreadsheet was constructed, determining the error in NCV for a variety of distances and NCVs. The average conduction time between proximal and distal stimulation was 3.23 ms, with a standard deviation of 0.09 ms. The mean distance measurement was 212.6 +/- 2.1 mm. The errors in NCV were significantly less than previously reported. The experimental error increased as distance decreased, reaching 20% with distances less than 6 cm. The latency error accounted for 71% of the total experimental error, as opposed to 90% in the previous study. With advances in electrodiagnostic equipment, NCV can reasonably be calculated at distances less than 10 cm, perhaps as low as 5-6 cm.
1972年,梅纳德和斯托洛夫指出,计算神经传导速度(NCV)时的实验误差取决于潜伏期和距离测量的误差。他们的数据表明,计算NCV时应使用至少10厘米的距离,因为距离较短时误差会增加≥25%。本研究的目的是利用当前技术重新确定最小距离。20名医生测量了存储的同一尺神经复合肌肉动作电位的近端和远端起始潜伏期以及前臂皮肤距离。确定了传导时间和距离误差的平均值和标准差。构建了一个电子表格,确定了各种距离和NCV下NCV的误差。近端和远端刺激之间的平均传导时间为3.23毫秒,标准差为0.09毫秒。平均距离测量值为212.6±2.1毫米。NCV的误差明显小于先前报道的误差。随着距离缩短,实验误差增加,距离小于6厘米时达到2