Parilla Barbara V, Leeth Elizabeth A, Kambich Michelle P, Chilis Patricia, MacGregor Scott N
Division of Maternal-Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Evanston Northwestern Healthcare, Northwestern University Medical School, Evanston, Illinois, USA.
J Ultrasound Med. 2003 Mar;22(3):255-8; quiz 259-61. doi: 10.7863/jum.2003.22.3.255.
To assess the accuracy of the prenatal diagnosis of skeletal dysplasias.
All antenatally detected anomalies are coded in our ultrasound database, which is linked with a genetics database that includes outcomes. A final diagnosis is sought on the basis of radiographic studies, molecular testing, or both. Our ultrasound and genetics databases were queried for "skeletal dysplasias." All cases were reviewed specifically for the degree of bone shortening and other distinguishing characteristics on antenatal sonography.
Thirty-seven cases of skeletal dysplasia were antenatally diagnosed over an 8-year period. Complete follow-up was available in 31 cases. The mean gestational age at diagnosis was 22.7 weeks (range, 14-32.3 weeks). Twenty-one cases were diagnosed before 24 weeks. A final diagnosis was obtained in 80% of cases. The antenatal diagnosis was correct in 20 (65%) of 31 cases. There were 2 false-positive diagnoses. Specific final diagnoses included thanatophoric dysplasia (8), osteogenesis imperfecta (6), Roberts syndrome (2), achondroplasia (3), Ellis-van Creveld syndrome (1), metaphyseal dysplasia (1), spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia (1), distal arthrogryposis (1), caudal regression (1), and glycogen storage disorder (1). The condition was correctly thought to be lethal in 16 of the fetuses on the basis of early severe long bone shortening (13), femur length-abdominal circumference ratio of less than 0.16 (12), hypoplastic thorax (10), marked bowing or fractures (4), short ribs (4), caudal regression (1), and cloverleaf skull (1). The ability to predict lethality was 100%. There were no false-positive findings with respect to lethality.
Accurate antenatal diagnosis of skeletal dysplasias is problematic; in this series, only 20 of 31 cases were correctly diagnosed. However, the antenatal prediction of lethality was highly accurate. The most common predictors of lethal skeletal dysplasias included early and severe shortening of the long bones, femur length-abdominal circumference ratio of less than 0.16, hypoplastic thorax, and certain distinguishing characteristics.
评估骨骼发育异常产前诊断的准确性。
所有产前检测到的异常情况都在我们的超声数据库中编码,该数据库与一个包含结局的遗传学数据库相关联。根据放射学研究、分子检测或两者来寻求最终诊断。我们在超声和遗传学数据库中查询“骨骼发育异常”。对所有病例专门复查产前超声检查时的骨骼缩短程度和其他鉴别特征。
在8年期间产前诊断出37例骨骼发育异常。31例有完整的随访资料。诊断时的平均孕周为22.7周(范围14 - 32.3周)。21例在24周前被诊断。80%的病例获得了最终诊断。31例中有20例(65%)产前诊断正确。有2例假阳性诊断。具体的最终诊断包括致死性侏儒症(8例)、成骨不全(6例)、罗伯茨综合征(2例)、软骨发育不全(3例)、埃利斯-范克里夫德综合征(1例)、干骺端发育异常(1例)、脊椎骨骺发育异常(1例)、远端关节挛缩症(1例)、尾椎退化综合征(1例)和糖原贮积病(1例)。基于早期严重的长骨缩短(13例)、股骨长度与腹围比值小于0.16(12例)、胸廓发育不全(10例)、明显弯曲或骨折(4例)、短肋骨(4例)、尾椎退化综合征(1例)和三叶形颅骨(1例),16例胎儿的病情被正确判断为致死性。预测致死性的能力为100%。在致死性方面没有假阳性发现。
骨骼发育异常的准确产前诊断存在问题;在本系列中,31例中只有20例被正确诊断。然而,产前致死性预测非常准确。致死性骨骼发育异常最常见的预测指标包括长骨早期严重缩短、股骨长度与腹围比值小于0.16、胸廓发育不全以及某些鉴别特征。