Moreau M, Dupuis J, Bonneau N H, Desnoyers M
Department of Clinical Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Montreal, 3200 Sicotte, PO Box 5000, St-Hyacinthe.
Vet Rec. 2003 Mar 15;152(11):323-9. doi: 10.1136/vr.152.11.323.
The efficacy, tolerance and ease of administration of a nutraceutical, carprofen or meloxicam were evaluated in a prospective, double-blind study on 71 dogs with osteoarthritis. The client-owned dogs were randomly assigned to one of the three treatments or to a placebo control group. The influence of osteoarthritis on the dogs' gait was described by comparing the ground reaction forces of the arthritic dogs and 10 normal dogs. Before the treatments began, and 30 and 60 days later, measurements were made of haematological and biochemical variables and of the ground reaction forces of the arthritic limb, and subjective assessments were made by the owners and by the orthopaedic surgeons. Changes in the ground reaction forces were specific to the arthritic joint, and were significantly improved by carprofen and meloxicam but not by the nutraceutical; the values returned to normal only with meloxicam. The orthopaedic surgeons assessed that there had been an improvement with carprofen and meloxicam, but the owners considered that there had been an improvement only with meloxicam. The blood and faecal analyses did not reveal any changes. The treatments were well tolerated, except for a case of hepatopathy in a dog treated with carprofen.
在一项针对71只患骨关节炎犬的前瞻性双盲研究中,评估了一种营养保健品、卡洛芬或美洛昔康的疗效、耐受性及给药便利性。这些客户自有的犬被随机分配至三种治疗方法之一或一个安慰剂对照组。通过比较患骨关节炎犬与10只正常犬的地面反作用力,描述了骨关节炎对犬步态的影响。在治疗开始前、30天及60天后,对血液学和生化指标以及患关节炎肢体的地面反作用力进行了测量,并由犬主和骨科医生进行主观评估。地面反作用力的变化特定于患关节炎的关节,卡洛芬和美洛昔康可使其显著改善,而营养保健品则无此效果;只有美洛昔康能使数值恢复正常。骨科医生评估卡洛芬和美洛昔康有改善效果,但犬主认为只有美洛昔康有改善效果。血液和粪便分析未显示任何变化。除了一只接受卡洛芬治疗的犬出现肝病病例外,这些治疗的耐受性良好。