de Faria Paulo Rogério, Cardoso Sérgio Vitorino, de A Nishioka Sérgio, Silva Sindeval José, Loyola Adriano Mota
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Pathology, Federal University of Uberlândia School of Dentistry, Av Pará 1720, bloco 2 N, 38 405-900 Uberlândia (MG), Brazil.
Clin Oral Investig. 2003 Mar;7(1):46-51. doi: 10.1007/s00784-002-0181-4. Epub 2003 Jan 23.
The ability to diagnose oral cancer depends in part on the knowledge, attitudes, and practices of the health professional. On the other hand, the patients' choice of health professional depends on their perceptions of the ability of such professionals to diagnose and treat what they believe their health problem is. In this study, we investigated the clinical profiles of patients with oral cancer ( n=354) when first seen by dentists ( n=129) or physicians ( n=225) in a teaching hospital. The charts of patients with oral squamous cell carcinoma were analyzed for the following variables: age, sex, race, signs and symptoms by the time of presentation to the health professional, size and site of the tumor since first manifestation, and clinical stage of the disease. Our results demonstrate that dentists and physicians assessed patients comparably regarding age, sex, and race. Patients complaining of dysphagia and odynophagia were seen more often by physicians than dentists (45/225 vs 9/129 [20.0% vs 7.0%] and 30/225 vs 4/129 [13.3% vs 3.1%], respectively), whereas those with local pain and burning preferentially sought dentists (77/129 vs 56/225 [59.7% vs 24.9%] and 4/129 [3.1%] vs 0/225, respectively). Physicians diagnosed oropharyngeal (45/208 vs 9/116 [21.6% vs 7.8%]) and lip lesions (71/208 vs 7/116 [34.1% vs 6.0%]) more often, whereas dentists saw more cases of cancer of the alveolar ridge (42/116 vs 7/208 [36.2% vs 3.4%]) and floor of the mouth (19/116 vs 10/208 [16.4% vs 4.8%]). Our findings suggest that patients have different perceptions of the roles of dentists and physicians regarding the ability to diagnose and treat oral lesions. Signs, symptoms, and location of the cancer lesions appear to be the most important variables associated with the choice of health professional.
口腔癌的诊断能力部分取决于医疗专业人员的知识、态度和实践。另一方面,患者对医疗专业人员的选择取决于他们对这些专业人员诊断和治疗其认为的健康问题能力的认知。在本研究中,我们调查了一家教学医院中,口腔癌患者(n = 354)首次被牙医(n = 129)或医生(n = 225)接诊时的临床特征。对口腔鳞状细胞癌患者的病历进行了以下变量分析:年龄、性别、种族、向医疗专业人员就诊时的体征和症状、自首次出现以来肿瘤的大小和部位,以及疾病的临床分期。我们的结果表明,牙医和医生在年龄、性别和种族方面对患者的评估相当。主诉吞咽困难和吞咽痛的患者被医生接诊的频率高于牙医(分别为45/225对9/129 [20.0%对7.0%]和30/225对4/129 [13.3%对3.1%]),而有局部疼痛和烧灼感的患者则更倾向于找牙医(分别为77/129对56/225 [59.7%对24.9%]和4/129 [3.1%]对0/225)。医生更常诊断口咽病变(45/208对9/116 [21.6%对7.8%])和唇部病变(71/208对7/116 [34.1%对6.0%]),而牙医看到的牙槽嵴癌(42/116对7/208 [36.2%对3.4%])和口底癌病例更多(19/116对10/208 [16.4%对4.8%])。我们的研究结果表明,患者对牙医和医生在诊断和治疗口腔病变能力方面的作用有不同的认知。癌症病变的体征、症状和部位似乎是与选择医疗专业人员相关的最重要变量。